WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM

Film Zulu Dawn quote: “Excuse me, my Lord, there's something I must convey to you. I rode along the track down to Rorke's Drift. The sky above is red with fire. Your orders my Lord? Do we move to the drift?”
 
HomeHome  GalleryGallery  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
Latest topics
» Henry William Longcast, Interpreter.
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyToday at 9:35 am by John Young

» HMS Active RMA and Kroomen duties
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySat Oct 24, 2020 10:39 pm by Herbie

» Famous death?
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySat Oct 24, 2020 3:38 pm by Frank Allewell

» N/5 Battery RA at Isandlwana
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySat Oct 24, 2020 10:20 am by SRB1965

» The Pickets on Mkwene
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Oct 23, 2020 11:30 am by Frank Allewell

» Durnford's medical officer
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Oct 23, 2020 9:51 am by Julian Whybra

» Victorian HMS SHAH South Africa Zulu Wars Medal William Morrison Royal Navy
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Oct 22, 2020 5:37 pm by Danny1960

» 1st Battalion, 24th (2nd Warwickshire) Regiment, 1875
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyMon Oct 19, 2020 12:29 pm by John Young

» The 'other' fighting clerk - Corporal JH Mayor, N.N.C
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySat Oct 17, 2020 5:07 am by Frank Allewell

» Somerset soldiers killed at Isandhlwana
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Oct 16, 2020 9:08 am by Julian Whybra

» "The Wiltshire Regiment 1756-1914"
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySat Oct 10, 2020 4:46 am by kaveman

» The Unknown Warrior Westminster Abbey
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Oct 07, 2020 3:06 pm by ADMIN

» Lance Corporal Robert Eaton NMP
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Oct 06, 2020 2:12 pm by Julian Whybra

» Lieutenant Anthony Kingscote, HMS Tenedos
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Oct 02, 2020 3:31 pm by Petty Officer Tom

» Sir Robert Gordon Gilmour
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Oct 01, 2020 4:22 pm by 90th

» William De Passey, 17th Lancers.1879.
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Oct 01, 2020 11:27 am by 1879graves

» Lieutenant Frederick Streatfield Pelly, RN
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 29, 2020 4:09 pm by 1879graves

» KEYNSHAMLIGHTHORSE GRAVES WEBSITE
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 29, 2020 8:08 am by ADMIN

» Regimental numbers
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 25, 2020 12:55 pm by Frank Allewell

» Isandlwana, Last Stands
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 25, 2020 9:13 am by Julian Whybra

» Colour of Lord Chelsmford eyes
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 25, 2020 8:05 am by Simonsole

» List of identified bodies at Isandlwana
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 17, 2020 5:30 am by John Young

» Defenders of Rorkes Drift
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 16, 2020 6:47 pm by Digger

» Colour Sgt Anthony Clark Booth, VC.
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 15, 2020 6:47 pm by ADMIN

» Cpl John Lyons
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyMon Sep 14, 2020 7:49 pm by Bill8183

» A Case of Mistaken Identity?
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyMon Sep 14, 2020 11:29 am by John Young

» What happened next
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyMon Sep 14, 2020 10:51 am by Springbok

» Surgeon Espine Charles Ward
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 09, 2020 9:38 am by John Young

» 2nd Lieutenant William Lancelot James, 2nd/4th Regiment.
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyMon Sep 07, 2020 2:41 pm by ADMIN

» Explaining Amabutho in one word??
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyMon Sep 07, 2020 11:49 am by SRB1965

» Non-Combat Casualties - Royal Navy and Royal Marines
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 03, 2020 4:05 pm by Frank Allewell

» Non-Combat Casualties - Royal Artillery
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 02, 2020 8:01 pm by Catiline63

» Colonel William,Egerton Saunders, C.B
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySun Aug 30, 2020 10:46 pm by ADMIN

» Lieutenant-Colonel David Campbell Williamson.
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySun Aug 30, 2020 10:32 pm by ADMIN

» Brigade Surgeon E. J. Boulton
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptySun Aug 30, 2020 10:02 pm by ADMIN

Search
 
 

Display results as :
 
Rechercher Advanced Search
Rorke's Drift BBC Radio 4
Top posters
90th
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Frank Allewell
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
littlehand
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
ADMIN
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
1879graves
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
rusteze
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Chelmsfordthescapegoat
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
John
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Mr M. Cooper
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Julian Whybra
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Top posting users this month
Frank Allewell
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Herbie
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Julian Whybra
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
John Young
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
aussie inkosi
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
90th
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Petty Officer Tom
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
SRB1965
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Isandula
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Danny1960
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_leftWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 BarWhy did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Bar_right 
Most active topics
Isandlwana, Last Stands
Durnford was he capable.1
Durnford was he capable. 4
Durnford was he capable.5
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The ammunition question
Durnford was he capable. 3
Durnford was he capable.2
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.
Most Viewed Topics
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.
Isandlwana, Last Stands
Adding to the Library
The ammunition question
Recent Members To The ZULU WAR 1879 Discussion & Reference Forum ( A Small Victorian War in 1879)
ISANDLWANA SURVIVIORS
Durnford was he capable.5
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
Lieutenant Adendorff 1-3 N.N.C.
Fair Use Notice
Fair use notice. This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner. We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website. If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution.
Keywords
Durnford Woolfryes drift martini henry Isandlwana horse payne harford Franklin gardner melvill taylor Police George Russell james spalding Prince Mounted smith 24th john Natal william zulu

 

 Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan

Go down 
Go to page : Previous  1, 2
AuthorMessage
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 09, 2014 9:03 pm

Mr Greaves wrote:
The Zulus that had shown them to Dartnell, could have launch an attack, Dartnell caught out in the open would not have stood a chance. The Zulus could have prevented messengers from Dartnell getting to the camp. why didn't they attack Dartnell?

It has not been proven that the Zulu Dartnell saw on the first day were from the impi...or even directly coordinating with it. In fact it's not even particularly likely.


Quote :
The next day we have eyewitness accounts from those out with LC  that the Zulu's were leading them further and further away from the camp. ?

True, but there are others that say the opposite and, in any case, correlation does not prove causality.  There is an adage that one tends to find what one is looking for.  That is very possibly the case here. "Leading them further and further away from the camp," is how it was characterized in the aftermath of the battle but the Zulu encountered might have been screening the main body...or just moving to join it.  There does not HAVE to be a trap; nor is it necessary that every action taken was part of some master plan put together by a single commander.  In fact the weight of evidence actually suggests it was not.  L&Q didn't conclusively "prove" there was a trap nor did they "prove" there was a conspiracy to frame Durnford.  They merely opened some interesting lines of speculation.  I think their latter case much stronger than the former.
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 09, 2014 10:31 pm

Dave wrote:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

This is a nearly perfect example of furthering an argument through both the "cherry picking" and careful omission of facts and qualifications that do not suit one's hypothesis.  An even handed evaluation does not retroactively cull through sources in order to force them into a predetermined argument. I would almost suspect Snook wrote it, but he's better than this.
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 09, 2014 10:50 pm

He is?. ignore this, i'm not stepping between you and Dave..
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 09, 2014 11:28 pm

xhosa2000 wrote:
He is?. ignore this, i'm not stepping between you and Dave..

Well, he was before his later books got completely dogmatic on the topic of Durnford.
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 10, 2014 3:34 am

6pdr wrote..
Well, he was before his later books got completely dogmatic on the topic of Durnford.



The absence of footnotes is to say the least problematic.
for a man of proven verbosity, it cant be lack of effort,
so their must have been another reason for their non
inclusion!. call me old fashioned, but i like my military
historians to demonstrate their meticulousness in
order that cross reference be enabled.. not to much to
ask, in order for one to be taken seriously.
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 10, 2014 3:54 am

xhosa2000 wrote:

The absence of footnotes is to say the least problematic.
for a man of proven verbosity, it cant be lack of effort,
so their must have been another reason for their non
inclusion!. call me old fashioned, but i like my military
historians to demonstrate their meticulousness in
order that cross reference be enabled.. not to much to
ask, in order for one to be taken seriously.

Agreed, but I'm talking about something even more basic. In his best book he acknowledged (even if he ultimately dismissed) factors which did not conveniently fit his thesis. There was a (usually brief) discussion of alternate points of view. Forget footnotes, the link Dave provided did not even qualify any of its assertions.
Back to top Go down
John

John

Posts : 2558
Join date : 2009-04-06
Age : 58
Location : UK

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyWed Sep 10, 2014 9:11 pm

Those Zulus that were in Dartnell's location, what was their roll, if it wasn't to decoy?
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 11, 2014 3:09 am

John wrote:
Those Zulus that were in Dartnell's location, what was their roll, if it wasn't to decoy?

See John, this is how we get off the tracks.  If you are asserting that there was a trap being laid the burden of proof rests squarely on you.  

But for the record, as I have already said, they were more likely local men (Matshana's boys.) It also possible they were on their way from their homes to join the main impi.  It's less likely (but possible) that Dartnell stumbled into a flanking force thrown out to screen the main impi.  

Keep in mind that Darnell was out searching a wide area.  During most of the reconnaissance on the first day his forces saw few people at all.

In any case there is no conclusive evidence that the men Darnell saw were under orders from the main body to draw the British troops away.  If you feel otherwise, present it.
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 11, 2014 3:08 pm

How does that prove a trap was laid? All it says is the enemy force split and we reacted.
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 11, 2014 4:41 pm

Cop out. It's either a proven fact or speculation. You are trying to have it both ways and there's no logic in that.
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 11, 2014 5:41 pm

Could you please explain the above statement, what am i trying to
have both way's?. my position on this has never wavered..
Back to top Go down
24th

24th

Posts : 1851
Join date : 2009-03-25

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 11, 2014 10:00 pm

6pdr wrote:
But for the record, as I have already said, they were more likely local men (Matshana's boys.) It also possible they were on their way from their homes to join the main impi.  It's less likely (but possible) that Dartnell stumbled into a flanking force thrown out to screen the main impi

So why would they have hung around Dartnells location, what was stopping them continuing to the main Impi.
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyThu Sep 11, 2014 10:48 pm

As highlighted by the 24th, ( the cut and paste has been iffy all day )
do you mean like a DECOY 6pdr?  Very Happy
Back to top Go down
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 12, 2014 1:05 am

24th wrote:
So why would they have hung around Dartnells location, what was stopping them continuing to the main Impi.

Again, the burden of proof doesn't lay with me.  Assertions in the form of questions won't prove a trap was laid, let alone that it was being done at the behest of Cetshwayo or the command of the main body command.

Credentialed professional historians doubt it can be proved and even the more populist tread carefully. Mike Snook (a man who requires no footnotes) in HOW CAN MEN DIE BETTER wrote on page 77: "At least two ostensibly unconnected youths said that the arrival of the big impi from Ulundi was now imminent, and that it would attack the British at Isandlwana in two days time. For whatever reason, and it may well have been because he resorted to brutality to get the information, Browne was now firmly convinced that he was in possession of the Zulu battle plan. It seems improbable that such insignificant figures, in such remote homesteads, could generally have been party to the plans of the Zulu high command..."

If there is one guy I thought might be willing to climb out on that limb it would be Snook but he doesn't.

Ian Knight, in his latest work ZULU RISING does agree (p.286) to the possibility (as do I, for that matter,) of a decoy, "Had they been, as some of the Volunteers suspected, trying to draw Dartnell into a trap?" Quite possibly; they knew, after all, what Dartnell did not -- that somewhere in the hills behind them lay the the long awaited main Zulu army."

Note however that Knight is NOT suggesting they were deployed there to make Chelmsford split his force in two. "That night Matshana's followers lit campfires on the slopes of Mangeni, intending the next morning not only to continue the march to the rendezvous point, but if possible to draw the British after them."

The British he is talking about are Darnell's detachment. Those men had already split away of course.  And Matshana's people lived local to the area of the Mangeni gorge.  His force was on its way to join the main body rather than being sent from the main impi as bait to trick the British into splitting their column further.
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 12, 2014 2:16 am

I did'nt expect amicability, but civility seems beyond you as well! 

"It does not much matter", so you agree with Ian do you? well all
above that begs to differ, you contradict yourself my friend! this
thread stays on here for eternity..you accuse people of cherry
picking..i must say your gall is breathtaking! i look forward to the
time you stop talking rubbish and post something of substance, its
your perogative to respond, or not to me! but when i present you 
with solid material, you glide over it like it never happened, not
good enough. i can spot bluster and hot air from miles away, i
can see why your such an admirer of the late Col, kindred spirits
alas. don't bother replying..no offence intended.
Back to top Go down
ADMIN

ADMIN

Posts : 3954
Join date : 2008-11-01
Age : 61
Location : KENT

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 12, 2014 3:02 pm

Off Topic can we stay on topic!
Back to top Go down
https://www.1879zuluwar.com
6pdr

6pdr

Posts : 1086
Join date : 2012-05-12
Location : NYC

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 12, 2014 3:22 pm

24th wrote:
So why would they have hung around Dartnells location, what was stopping them continuing to the main Impi.

BTW, did those Zulu hang around Dartnell's location? I mean maybe the fires were lit to mask their departure. That's the decoy, right? Or are we talking apples and oranges?
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyFri Sep 12, 2014 3:26 pm

Understood admin, i never bear grudges, its always a fresh start with me!  Very Happy
i well understand this place is more important than any individual!! i am 
always acutely aware of that, as the old saying goes...it takes a big man ect.
Back to top Go down
Frank Allewell

Frank Allewell

Posts : 7600
Join date : 2009-09-21
Age : 73
Location : Cape Town South Africa

Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 16, 2014 11:23 am

Possibly another reason as to why there were so many Zulus around Dartnells force.
Uguku of the umCijo

The army was under the joint command of Mavumengwana, Tsingwayo and Sihayo. It was intended that Matshana kaMondisa was to be chief in command but he had been a Natal kafir, the other three were jealous of him and did not like him to be put over them; they therefore devised a plan of getting him out of the way on the day of the battle, They accomplished this plan by getting him to go forward with Undwandwe to the Upindo to reconnoitre and promised to follow. As soon as he had gone they took another road, viz., north of Babanango, while Matshana and Undwandwe went south of it, being accompanied by 6 mavigo (companies). It was our intention to have rested for a day in the valley where we arrived the night before the battle, but having on the morning of the battle heard firing of the English advanced guard who had engaged Matshanas men..............

So pretty clear from Uguku that the forces of Matshana were the ones who engaged the column. No master plan of decoy there.

Cheers
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 EmptyTue Sep 16, 2014 1:05 pm

When i think of the Zulu ' master Plan ' i think of thousands of ants
all co-operating with a common purpose, each individual supporting
the whole, all with the same objective in mind!. the result was a
foregone conclusion.
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content




Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan   Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan - Page 2 Empty

Back to top Go down
 
Why did Lord Chelmsford return to Isandlwana on the 22nd Jan
Back to top 
Page 2 of 2Go to page : Previous  1, 2

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM  :: GENERAL DISCUSSION AREA-
Jump to: