WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM

Lt. Melvill: Well done, Sir! Did you see that Noggs? Deceived him with the up and took him with the down. Norris-Newman: Well well, this one's a grandfather at least. If he'd been a Zulu in his prime I'd have given odds against your lancer, Mr.Melvill.
 
HomeHome  CalendarCalendar  GalleryGallery  PublicationsPublications  FAQFAQ  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
Latest topics
» What to do with your research when you have passed away.
Today at 3:48 pm by Gardner1879

» LEGACY: Heroes of Rorke's Drift' by Kris Wheatley
Today at 1:13 pm by louisafilby

» Medal auction
Yesterday at 10:23 am by Gardner1879

» Regimental Paylists
Sat Jul 14, 2018 11:37 pm by Bill8183

» Bassage Diary
Sat Jul 14, 2018 3:34 am by 90th

» The first battle fought in Africa by the 24th?
Wed Jul 11, 2018 4:47 pm by Frank Allewell

» Admiral Sir James Startin, K.C.B., A.M
Mon Jul 09, 2018 11:14 am by John Young

» Most Recent Members 2018
Sun Jul 08, 2018 6:32 pm by ADMIN

» "ISANDULA COLLECTION"
Sun Jul 08, 2018 6:20 pm by ADMIN

» William Allen rededication at Monmouth cemetery. 4th July 2018
Sun Jul 08, 2018 5:56 pm by ADMIN

» 25B/778 Pte. Evan Williams
Sun Jul 08, 2018 5:52 pm by ADMIN

» British Empire - an Equivocation
Sun Jul 08, 2018 1:43 am by xhosa2000

» Isandhlwana survivor of N/5 ??
Fri Jul 06, 2018 9:17 pm by Tim Needham

»  John McCoy b. 1844, Ireland d. 11/04/1881, Transvaal, South Africa
Wed Jul 04, 2018 2:48 am by anorakABO

» New Version of Snook's Isandlwana Book?
Tue Jul 03, 2018 10:56 pm by Julian Whybra

Lt. (Brevet Major) J.R.M. Chard, 5th Field Company, Royal Engineers--Rorke's Drift and Ulundi
(Mac and Shad) Isandula Collection)
Rededication Rorke's Drift Defender William Wilcox. 8th May 2011 Dolton Devon.
Search
 
 

Display results as :
 
Rechercher Advanced Search
Top posters
90th
 
littlehand
 
Frank Allewell
 
ADMIN
 
1879graves
 
rusteze
 
Chelmsfordthescapegoat
 
John
 
Mr M. Cooper
 
impi
 
Fair Use Notice
Fair use notice. This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner. We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website. If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution.
Top posting users this month
rusteze
 
Frank Allewell
 
90th
 
Kenny
 
John Young
 
Julian Whybra
 
xhosa2000
 
Bill8183
 
SRB1965
 
ADMIN
 
Most active topics
Isandlwana, Last Stands
Durnford was he capable.5
Durnford was he capable. 4
Durnford was he capable.1
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The ammunition question
Durnford was he capable.2
Durnford was he capable. 3
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.

Share | 
 

 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.

Go down 
AuthorMessage
SRB1965

avatar

Posts : 506
Join date : 2017-05-13
Age : 53
Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....

PostSubject: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Sun Nov 05, 2017 5:06 pm

Hi

A hypothetical question - What do people think, would have happened if the garrison of Rorke's Drift had say four or five hours notice of the impending Zulu attack occurring?

Would Spalding have reinforced RD with the companies from Helpmakker or would the garrison have fell back to Helpmakker and left the stores undefended?

Cheers

Sime

Back to top Go down
90th

avatar

Posts : 9620
Join date : 2009-04-07
Age : 62
Location : Melbourne, Australia

PostSubject: '' What If '' RD Question    Mon Nov 06, 2017 12:12 am

Hi Sime
Hard to say , they were ordered , I think by Gardner ( Pencil Note ) to hold the position at all costs ? , even then , flight was on their mind at their earliest stage of preparedness , they did stay because they were aware they couldn't out run the zulus . But with 4 or 5 hrs notice , who knows.... they may well have ' Legged It ' ! .
90th Very Happy
Back to top Go down
SRB1965

avatar

Posts : 506
Join date : 2017-05-13
Age : 53
Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Tue Nov 07, 2017 4:54 pm

Hi,

You have to wonder, was Gardner's order a realistic one, he had just seen the Zulus overwhelm six companies of 24th (+ supporting elements), did not know the strength of the Zulus adavancing on Rorkes Drift (true he did not know the two companies from Helpmakker had not arrived) and he had no idea that the garrison would improvise defences.

I think, if his order had any influence on the garrisons decision to hold and things had gone badly, he would have had to do some soul searching.....
Back to top Go down
SRB1965

avatar

Posts : 506
Join date : 2017-05-13
Age : 53
Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Tue Nov 07, 2017 6:59 pm

SRB1965 wrote:
Hi,

You have to wonder, was Gardner's order a realistic one, he had just seen the Zulus overwhelm six companies of 24th (+ supporting elements), did not know the strength of the Zulus adavancing on Rorkes Drift (true he did not know the two companies from Helpmakker had not arrived) and he had no idea that the garrison would improvise defences.

I think, if his order had any influence on the garrisons decision to hold and things had gone badly, he would have had to do some soul searching.....

Plus, if you think about it - the Officer in charge of RD (as far as Gardner was aware), was Brevet Major Spalding - I do not know much about a Staff Officer's role but could they give orders not from their commander (ie in this case Col Glyn) to an officer superior to themselves?

Hope this last bit isn't too confussing......

Sime
Back to top Go down
N.B.Forrest

avatar

Posts : 30
Join date : 2016-07-21
Age : 68
Location : East Anglia

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Sun Feb 11, 2018 6:15 pm

Do we know what sort of person he was in military terms? Was he the sort to stay put and 'tough it out' or would he have been more cautious and fallen back on Helpmekaar as the best option? Did he have previous military experience that would at least give us a clue?

Given in this scenario that he had a few hours’ notice of what was on its way to him and assuming he also knew about the fate of the main column, it seems likely to me that he may have seen fit to err on the side of caution and evacuate RK as best he could. However, if he had a direct order to hold his position, then I'd like to think that he would have done so.


Back to top Go down
90th

avatar

Posts : 9620
Join date : 2009-04-07
Age : 62
Location : Melbourne, Australia

PostSubject: What If RD question    Mon Feb 12, 2018 5:09 am

Hi NB Forrest
They could not have evacuated the post even if they wanted to , they had 30 or so sick people in the hospital , they didn't have long before they were attacked , an hour ? ( happy to be corrected ) they would've been cut down on the road to Helpmekaar , it's a steep climb with wagons laden with sick individuals , they would've been easy pickings for the zulu when caught on the open road .
90th
Back to top Go down
90th

avatar

Posts : 9620
Join date : 2009-04-07
Age : 62
Location : Melbourne, Australia

PostSubject: What If RD question    Mon Feb 12, 2018 5:12 am

also forgot to mention , it was either Cochrane or Gardner ..who did indeed pencil a note to the commanding officer at RD , stating they were to hold their ground .
90th Salute
Back to top Go down
SRB1965

avatar

Posts : 506
Join date : 2017-05-13
Age : 53
Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Mon Feb 12, 2018 7:23 am

Hi 90th

It was a hypothetical question about what if the garrison had 4/5 hours to 'do one'. There is no wrong or right answer, I was just making small talk......

Can anyone tell me what the remit of a Staff Officer was? - Could they issue orders to superior officers (potentially B Maj Spadling) on their own behalf or did they only have the 'authority' to forward their superiors orders?

I am interested in could Gardner issue an order to the garrison to defend the place.

Cheers

Sime
Back to top Go down
90th

avatar

Posts : 9620
Join date : 2009-04-07
Age : 62
Location : Melbourne, Australia

PostSubject: What If RD question    Mon Feb 12, 2018 8:23 am

Hi Sime
I was replying to the question asked by N.B. Forrest , actually not to your post Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy , to answer your question about staff officers issuing orders to superior ranked officers , I suppose they could in certain circumstances , seems they did ! lollll .
90th Salute
Back to top Go down
SRB1965

avatar

Posts : 506
Join date : 2017-05-13
Age : 53
Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Mon Feb 12, 2018 8:38 am

I will get to bottom of the Staff Officers role......and was Gardner exceeding his authority (as he shot of towards Dundee or where-ever).....if it kills me......

Ta

Sime

Back to top Go down
N.B.Forrest

avatar

Posts : 30
Join date : 2016-07-21
Age : 68
Location : East Anglia

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Mon Feb 12, 2018 9:04 am

Thanks for the reply 90th, in actual fact my question was continuing the 'What if' scenario of extra time being available before the onset of attack. Yes, I was aware of the sick in the hospital and the nature of the track back to Helpmekaar. Just wondered what sort of experience Spalding had which may (or may not) have coloured his decision to either chance an evacuation or stay put!

I will be intrigued to hear what you discover about the military validity or otherwise of the Cochrane/Gardner note.

Thanks again
Back to top Go down
SRB1965

avatar

Posts : 506
Join date : 2017-05-13
Age : 53
Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....

PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   Mon Feb 12, 2018 9:11 am

I may put the Gardner question as a separate thread, the fact there are two questions here - a hypothetical discussion one (with no 'answer') and one that there must be an answer to (and someone on the forum will have it) is perhaps confusing.

Cheers

Simon
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content




PostSubject: Re: 'What if' Rorkes Drift question.   

Back to top Go down
 
'What if' Rorkes Drift question.
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM  :: ZULU WAR BATTLES-
Jump to: