Latest topics | » 1409 Pte David Lloyd, Defender of Rorke's DriftToday at 8:19 am by Julian Whybra » The curious tale of Cetshwayo's "gunpowder depot" and an aggressive snakeYesterday at 9:36 am by Hobbes » Anson A. Mayer/MaherTue Apr 23, 2024 7:10 pm by cmeghen » Late Father's Militaria CollectionSun Apr 21, 2024 2:16 pm by Julian Whybra » A Hungarian soldier in the Zulu War (?)Sun Apr 21, 2024 11:28 am by Eddie » Lieut. B. Pohl, No. 7 Coy 1/3 Natal Native ContingentSat Apr 20, 2024 9:26 am by SRB1965 » Alfred Fairlie Henderson photographs.Fri Apr 19, 2024 7:04 am by John Young » No. 985. PTE. EDWARD READ. 2-24 Regt. (South Wales Borders).Sun Apr 14, 2024 8:12 pm by Julian Whybra » Private Willis 2/24th Regiment his letter from South AfricaSat Apr 13, 2024 2:49 pm by 1879graves » Sickness among Crealock's menFri Apr 12, 2024 4:52 pm by Hobbes » Wheeler John Cantwell DCM, RD survivor of the Royal Horse ArtilleryTue Apr 09, 2024 5:20 pm by Kenny » Brevet Major W.R.B. ChamberlinSun Apr 07, 2024 5:44 pm by Jager1 » Private 1941 Samuel MacClue / McClune 1/24th RegimentSun Apr 07, 2024 3:11 pm by Dash » Sergeant W E Warren RA - VeteranSun Apr 07, 2024 10:50 am by DavidS » "With 6 good riflemen"Sat Apr 06, 2024 5:10 pm by Hobbes » Punch's view of Chelmsford's tactics!Wed Apr 03, 2024 5:17 pm by SRB1965 » Colonialism: A Moral LegacyMon Apr 01, 2024 11:16 am by Julian Whybra » John Robert DunnSat Mar 30, 2024 12:09 pm by 90th » An early memorial to the Prince Imperial?Sat Mar 30, 2024 10:35 am by John Young » The Poem "A Child Hero" referring to Rupert WeatherleyFri Mar 29, 2024 1:07 pm by Bongo » Writing adviceTue Mar 26, 2024 2:26 pm by Julian Whybra » Private John Scott 24th Regiment a fugitive at largeWed Mar 20, 2024 12:53 pm by Dash » Your favourite line from Zulu or Zulu DawnTue Mar 19, 2024 4:52 pm by Julian Whybra » 100,000 posts!Tue Mar 19, 2024 2:20 pm by Julian Whybra » Zulu Dawn/Zulu - New Immortals Film The Way Forward ?Sat Mar 16, 2024 2:34 pm by jgregory » Badge on 2/60th and 3/60th foreign service helmets Sat Mar 16, 2024 11:05 am by John Young » Corporal James Frowen Williams F Company. Fri Mar 15, 2024 9:08 am by Julian Whybra » British rations and moraleMon Mar 11, 2024 11:05 pm by Julian Whybra » Blue Plaque to James Egan, alias Private HaganMon Mar 11, 2024 9:16 pm by ADMIN» A few questions regarding Rorke's Drift and IsandlwanaWed Mar 06, 2024 9:16 pm by Julian Whybra » William J Hoare 24th Regiment??Sun Mar 03, 2024 7:08 pm by Dash » Swinburn Carbine issue in AZWThu Feb 29, 2024 12:53 pm by Rob D » Australians who went to Zululand and fought in the 1879 war.Thu Feb 29, 2024 8:39 am by John Young » Philip Price Thu Feb 29, 2024 7:55 am by Julian Whybra » Alfred Fairlie Henderson Thu Feb 29, 2024 7:47 am by RoryReynolds |
April 2024 | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun |
---|
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | | | | | | Calendar |
|
Top posting users this month | |
New topics | » The curious tale of Cetshwayo's "gunpowder depot" and an aggressive snakeWed Apr 24, 2024 3:26 pm by Hobbes » Lieut. B. Pohl, No. 7 Coy 1/3 Natal Native ContingentSat Apr 20, 2024 12:38 am by WeekendWarrior » Alfred Fairlie Henderson photographs.Fri Apr 19, 2024 7:04 am by John Young » Late Father's Militaria CollectionThu Apr 18, 2024 3:04 pm by A Crockart » Anson A. Mayer/MaherTue Apr 16, 2024 5:28 pm by cmeghen » A Hungarian soldier in the Zulu War (?)Sun Apr 14, 2024 8:01 pm by Hobbes » Sickness among Crealock's menThu Apr 11, 2024 8:51 pm by Hobbes » Wheeler John Cantwell DCM, RD survivor of the Royal Horse ArtillerySun Apr 07, 2024 9:36 pm by Hobbes » John Robert DunnSat Mar 30, 2024 11:47 am by SueSNB |
Zero tolerance to harassment and bullying. |
Due to recent events on this forum, we have now imposed a zero tolerance to harassment and bullying. All reports will be treated seriously, and will lead to a permanent ban of both membership and IP address.
Any member blatantly corresponding in a deliberate and provoking manner will be removed from the forum as quickly as possible after the event.
If any members are being harassed behind the scenes PM facility by any member/s here at 1879zuluwar.com please do not hesitate to forward the offending text.
We are all here to communicate and enjoy the various discussions and information on the Anglo Zulu War of 1879. Opinions will vary, you will agree and disagree with one another, we will have debates, and so it goes.
There is no excuse for harassment or bullying of anyone by another person on this site.
The above applies to the main frame areas of the forum.
The ring which is the last section on the forum, is available to those members who wish to partake in slagging matches. That section cannot be viewed by guests and only viewed by members that wish to do so. |
Fair Use Notice | Fair use notice.
This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner.
We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes.
We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website.
If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution. |
| | Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. | |
|
+7Chelmsfordthescapegoat littlehand John Young ymob Frank Allewell impi DrummerBoy 16 11 posters | |
Author | Message |
---|
24th
Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Tue Mar 25, 2014 6:25 pm | |
| I suspect most of those who claimed to have seen the two together did so just before they rode in to the river. |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Fri Apr 18, 2014 2:43 pm | |
| If you read accounts of battles, most eye-witnesses can recall seeing x and y but not necessarily when precisely and at what geographical point. In the unfamiliar country along which the flight occurred this will be especially the case. The only exceptions will be when something particular occurred which stood out in the memory or something was said which made an impression on the listener. Bickley is a good example. Both Coghill and Melvill would be well-known to Bickley (so no fear of misidentification). Witnessing Coghill's report to the adjutant that the Colonel had been shot would also have stood out in Bickley's memory. Bickley SAW Coghill speak to Melvill and OVERHEARD the remark. It is undoubtedly true. The others mentioned would all have known both officers and undoubtedly saw them - from memory I believe Brickhill and Foley also mention Coghill and/or Melvill in their accounts. I'm sure as the two officers rode, sometimes they were together and sometimes not as they were mixed up in the melee. At the point where they entered the drift they were together (and undoubtedly with Higginson). Higginson knowingly put himself in line for criticism by saying he went off to find some horses - he might have done better to remain quiet - I suspect he didn't in case anyone had witnessed the event. |
| | | impi
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Fri Apr 18, 2014 8:02 pm | |
| I don't think we can say for certain, they entered the drift together. We know Coghill was on the other side of the river when he saw Melville struggling, and went back to help.
You also have to take into account. Smith's and Curling's statement. |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 9:46 am | |
| Yes, that's broadly speaking what I meant by 'together' - close enough to be within reach of helping one another. |
| | | 24th
Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 10:43 am | |
| It seems a bit of an odd statement in that, M & C made a pact to stick together, when you consider they were both officers, and men all around trying to escape. Would have made more sense to have made a pact with all the men in the vincinty. We know that Coghill left first, and was seen on the trail. We also know that Melvill was seen behind Coghil. Is it then not possible that someone had told Coghill that Melvill was behind with the colours forcing Coghill to either wait for him, thus when Melvill caught up, the conversation took place or did Coghill ride back to assist Melvill. |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 2:01 pm | |
| 24th The sort of precision you seek with regard to events during the flight is simply not possible given what was reported. Beyond that, all is speculation. |
| | | 24th
Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 6:22 pm | |
| I expect that goes for Higginson's account? |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 7:03 pm | |
| Not necessarily but possibly in some areas. I've already given an opinion on Higginson; the need for cross-referencing for corroboration is self-evident. |
| | | impi
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 8:22 pm | |
| Corroboration while on the trail and in the water, after that speculation. How many actually saw Melvill and Coghill's horses shot while in the water? |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 8:34 pm | |
| impi My notes tell me that the accounts of Pte. Bickley, Curling, Smith-Dorrien, Pte. Williams, Higginson, and Foley mention meeting Melvill AND Coghill in flight. Why not check their accounts out for yourself if you're interested? No other survivor's account mentions them. One thing to bear in mind re veracity when reading any survivor's account is the fact that he could not guarantee that another survivor was not witnessing the same event and that therefore his account might be challenged. Lying or story-inflation post eventum, if proven to be the case, would be pretty pointless and reputation-damaging especially for an officer (witness Lieut. L. Young N.N.C.).
Last edited by Julian Whybra on Sat Apr 19, 2014 8:42 pm; edited 1 time in total |
| | | impi
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 8:39 pm | |
| That what I said corroboration on the trail. I'm not doubting that! No need to check accounts. |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 8:45 pm | |
| Well, do as you wish, but as a general rule I always check the original accounts BEFORE I make any potentially earth-shaking comment. I can at least then be sure of not being shot down in flames. Note that the flight extended to and beyond the river! |
| | | impi
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 8:56 pm | |
| And what was this earth shaking comment, I supposedly made. |
| | | Chard1879
Posts : 1261 Join date : 2010-04-12
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 10:43 pm | |
| |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sat Apr 19, 2014 11:31 pm | |
| I'm not aware you've ever made one. I was writing hypothetically...if you were to make one, so to speak. |
| | | Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 12:20 am | |
| |
| | | littlehand
Posts : 7076 Join date : 2009-04-24 Age : 55 Location : Down South.
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 12:35 am | |
| Would a revolver back in 1879 have functioned after being in water? Black powder, not sure ammunition technology went a far a water-proofing. Perhaps Neil could help? |
| | | impi
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 12:40 am | |
| - Julian Whybra wrote:
- Well, do as you wish, but as a general rule I always check the original accounts BEFORE I make any potentially earth-shaking comment. I can at least then be sure of not being shot down in flames.
Note that the flight extended to and beyond the river! Perhaps in-directly aimed at me. Regarding the earthing Shaking comment! |
| | | impi
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 12:42 am | |
| - littlehand wrote:
- Would a revolver back in 1879 have functioned after being in water? Black powder, not sure ammunition technology went a far a water-proofing. Perhaps Neil could help?
Good Point LH. |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 9:08 am | |
| LH A good point, yes, but I recall Sparks, I think, firing his revolver after the river to keep his pursuers away. I'll check his and others' accounts.
impi You have an incredible knack of getting the wrong end of the stick. In your post you asked who else saw Melvill and Coghill in flight. I gave you a list of who did and suggested you look up their accounts yourself. You then said there was no need to check accounts. I then said it was always wise to check written comments before making any pronouncements. Nothing was 'aimed' at you. I was trying to be helpful. |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 9:59 am | |
| LH I just checked. It wasn't Sparks; it was Smith-Dorrien who, after swimming the river, kept his pursuers away by using his revolver. |
| | | Mr Greaves
Posts : 747 Join date : 2009-10-18
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 10:07 am | |
| I was just, going to ask which "Sparks" source you quote from? |
| | | Julian Whybra
Posts : 3959 Join date : 2011-09-12 Location : Billericay, Essex
| Subject: Re: Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. Sun Apr 20, 2014 11:59 am | |
| Mr. Greaves I checked only the account in Clements, W. H., The Glamour and Tragedy of the Zulu War, (London, 1936), p. 63, not the 1929 one or the anecdote in Holt. I was looking specifically at his story after crossing the river. |
| | | | Did Coghill Meet Melville, Before Entering The River. | |
|
Similar topics | |
|
| Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |