WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM

Film Zulu Quote:Lieutenant John Chard: The army doesn't like more than one disaster in a day. Lieutenant Gonville Bromhead: Looks bad in the newspapers and upsets civilians at their breakfast..
 
HomeHome  GalleryGallery  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
Latest topics
» H.M.S. Forester
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyToday at 11:58 am by John Young

» Best book on colonial soldiers during zulu war
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyToday at 7:47 am by John Young

» Royal Small Arms Repair Factory - Pimlico / Mill Bank , London
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed May 18, 2022 2:04 pm by MPS1

» Deafness linked to the effects of battle
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon May 16, 2022 1:56 pm by Younghusband

» Brevet Major Walter Parke Jones, R. E.
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun May 15, 2022 7:29 pm by ADMIN

» Zulu campfires
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun May 08, 2022 11:28 am by John Young

» Stations of Regiments mid 1870's (UK)
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun May 08, 2022 11:26 am by John Young

» Nevill Coghill's nephew
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyFri Apr 29, 2022 10:09 am by Julian Whybra

» Uniform - Natal Circa 1895?
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun Apr 24, 2022 11:44 am by Rory Reynolds

» Isandlwana solving the enigma
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyFri Apr 22, 2022 2:48 pm by Julian Whybra

» John Wyndon Lyon
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyThu Apr 21, 2022 6:38 pm by Julian Whybra

» No. 1488 Color Sergeant A. Spalding
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyTue Apr 19, 2022 9:35 pm by John Young

» Pin pointing an ASC man's war
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySat Apr 16, 2022 12:55 pm by Rory Reynolds

» Trooper David Doig, father-in-law Trooper Robert Adams
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon Apr 11, 2022 3:42 pm by Julian Whybra

» Pte 922 George Edwards (Alias Orchard) and Pte 2744 Charles Moore
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Apr 06, 2022 7:47 pm by 1879graves

» 4709 Gunner Ernest Jones N/5 R.A.
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Apr 06, 2022 12:33 pm by Woolwich

» Frederick Montague 83728 RN HMS Boadicea 1879 (Missing 1914/15 Star and Victory Medal)
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyTue Apr 05, 2022 11:48 pm by OC1

» Updated List of Royal Navy Medals Known to Exist
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon Apr 04, 2022 8:31 pm by Petty Officer Tom

» The Mystery of the Missing Mainwaring Material
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon Apr 04, 2022 5:03 pm by WeekendWarrior

» Looking for the medal to 1423 Pte. W. Gregg/Greig
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyFri Apr 01, 2022 6:54 pm by Kenny

» Help Please
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 31, 2022 6:01 pm by John Young

» James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 11:56 pm by aussie inkosi

» Barker and the Rocket Battery
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 28, 2022 12:15 pm by Frank Allewell

» Renamed medals?
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 28, 2022 6:40 am by 90th

» S.SMITH Buffalo Border Guard
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySat Mar 26, 2022 7:47 am by Brett Hendey

» Seeking Primary Sources
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 24, 2022 8:46 am by aussie inkosi

» Dead Was Everything: Studies in the Anglo-Zulu War. Keith Smith
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 24, 2022 7:21 am by aussie inkosi

» Pte H Brown 6th Lanc Fus
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 20, 2022 11:11 pm by Sturgy

» ‘Isandula Mountain, Zululand’
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyTue Mar 15, 2022 11:43 am by Julian Whybra

» Private MJ Flood 57th Foot
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyMon Mar 14, 2022 7:25 pm by Alfie

» Richie's new Zulu War model figure project - cast your vote now
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 13, 2022 11:06 pm by PhilJ

» Natal Witness 'mystery' death notice
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySun Mar 13, 2022 9:29 am by Julian Whybra

» Sapper M Leahy RE
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptySat Mar 12, 2022 12:08 am by Sturgy

» Corporal J Quail 1/13th Foot
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 10, 2022 11:11 am by Sturgy

» Sergeant Major Dan Scott
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyThu Mar 10, 2022 10:15 am by aussie inkosi

Search
 
 

Display results as :
 
Rechercher Advanced Search
The Battle of Isandlwana: From above
Top posters
90th
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Frank Allewell
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
littlehand
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
ADMIN
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
1879graves
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
rusteze
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Julian Whybra
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Chelmsfordthescapegoat
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
John
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Mr M. Cooper
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Top posting users this month
John Young
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
ciroferrara
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Frank Allewell
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
90th
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Younghusband
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Herbie
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Bill8183
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
MPS1
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Isandula
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Kenny
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_leftJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 BarJames Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Bar_right 
Most active topics
Durnford was he capable.1
Durnford was he capable. 4
Durnford was he capable.5
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
Isandlwana, Last Stands
The ammunition question
Durnford was he capable. 3
Durnford was he capable.2
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.
Most Viewed Topics
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.
Isandlwana, Last Stands
Adding to the Library
The ammunition question
ISANDLWANA SURVIVIORS
Recent Members To The ZULU WAR 1879 Discussion & Reference Forum ( A Small Victorian War in 1879)
Durnford was he capable.5
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
Lieutenant Adendorff 1-3 N.N.C.
Fair Use Notice
Fair use notice. This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner. We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website. If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution.
Keywords
24th drift carbineers Prince Franklin martini Isandlwana henry Natal horse Durnford Police william harford taylor Russell spalding brown john zulu George payne smith Woolfryes Mounted james
 

 James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance

Go down 
+3
Julian Whybra
Frank Allewell
aussie inkosi
7 posters
Go to page : Previous  1, 2
AuthorMessage
Tig Van Milcroft




Posts : 50
Join date : 2022-02-21

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyTue Mar 29, 2022 1:57 pm

Frank, I also have niggles about that message. It says everything and nothing, everything if you think the main Zulu Impi is advancing and nothing if it refers to a small force of Zulus advancing. It does capture the paucity of accurate information in the posession of Pulleine at the time (8-05am) of the Zulu intentions. It should though have caused a reaction from Chelmsford who until this point had no reservations as to the security of his flank in this direction.

If as I pointed out in an earlier post Chelmsford had co-ordinated Vedette information to go through himself rather than be filtered by the Camp he would have a better perspective of the relative threats to the entire force.

Chelmsford had allowed a very large Zulu force to insert itself undetected between the two elements of his divided command and failed to co-ordinate the flow analysis and assessment of intelligence received, of which there was much of substance.

Back to top Go down
Tig Van Milcroft




Posts : 50
Join date : 2022-02-21

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyTue Mar 29, 2022 2:16 pm

This thread started off about the action on and around the Spur. I have looked at Ansteys map and Mainwaring maps, of the two Ansteys map looks much the most accurate when I compare to the (I hope) real world of Google. Vedette A and the NNC Piquet are marked, though I do not know if there is a real world actual posiiton established for the NNC Piquet. The position marked on Ansteys map provides much better visibility to the NW than the N & NE, but the Vedette A could compensate for this.

Referencing Clery on Minor Tactics, the Piquest requires patrolling from and a relatively speaking strong and defensable position sometihng like a Kraal would serve somewhere atop the Spur and close to the trackway. The strength of the piquet sufficient to provide support to patrols under fire, to defend itself against attack and or to be able to conduct a fighting retreat to the main body. This would require the piquet position to have one or both flanks secured, which suggest a positon close to the trackway and the escarpement edge.

There does not appear to have been much patrolling going on by the NNC, they were probably all together in the piquet, this would of course limit the intel quite a lot. For anybody used to receiving reports from a Regular Army piquet this may well lead to a misintepretation of what actually was going on.

This Piquet positioning and logic outlined in Minor Tactics is similar to infantry support to advancing cavalry such as Durnford requested before leaving camp, which begs a further question as to what level of support Durnford was actually requesting of Pulleine. I suggest that this could be a little as a company told off to give fire support to a retreating cavalry, not requiring a loss of contact with the main camp defense.
Back to top Go down
Julian Whybra




Posts : 2862
Join date : 2011-09-12
Location : Billericay, Essex

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyTue Mar 29, 2022 5:21 pm

Frank
Pulleine's behaviour comes back to adherence to Clery's order: "...but keep your cavalry still far advanced", "keep your cavalry still far advanced", and "keep a sharp look out with your Cavalry" i.e. NOTHING added about 'sending out cavalry patrols or reconnaissance'.
Pulleine simply believed what LC - Clery - Crealock were saying viz. that the main impi lay on the track ahead and they left that morning to intercept it.
Back to top Go down
aussie inkosi

aussie inkosi


Posts : 371
Join date : 2013-09-16
Age : 56
Location : MELBOURNE

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 9:13 am

Tig Van Milcroft wrote:
Aussie, Back home. Your points include some assumptions that may or may not be correct, we will probably never know. But to eleborate.

That 5000 Zulus were moving north of the camp was the reason the Durnford instructed a reconnaissance. 5000 Zulus were not likely to overcome the firepower available in the camp. Even less so if their position and strength was understood before there approached it. 

Until Durnford's arrival in camp a reconnaissance was not possible because there were so few mounted troops left by Chelmsford. That infers that there was no serious threat to camp anticipated by the commanding officer Chelmsford. Orders were left to "defend the camp" though I have not seen a transcript of the full order. No experienced officer would leave a camp denuded of reconnaissance troops, and with more than half of its firepower mobilised to attack a "stronghold" 12 miles remote formt he camp, if there was any risk of the full force of the enemy army could be applied to the camp in its absence. That was the mindset of everybody engaged in the British force prior to Raw's discovery.

Pulleine himself may have instructed a similar reconnaissance if he had the forces able to carry it out prior to Durnford's arrival, I think this is likely, he had experience of mounted forces and their uses.

The only point of difference was the disagreement about taking Imp Infantry. The outcome would have been very different if RAW,Durnford Barton and Roberts had drawn 5000 Zulus in to attack the camp rather than the 20,000 that actually did.

To take you second point about standing back to back etc, Pulleine could have ordered this, at any time after receving Raws report. He did not, the responsibility for not doing so is his. That is not to say that what you suggest was or was not the best option. The "drawing of men out of camp" caused few casualties amongst Imp Forces and we know many more in the Zulu forces, especially those facing the retreating Basutos in the Dongas. Concentration may still have been an option even late on, before it became the last ditch option for individual companies prior to complete rout.

The "Back to back" stance you describe would be completely appropriate, if you believe you were deploying in advance to face 20,000 Zulus, that was sinmply not the case here. Pulleine deployed to "Defend the camp" not the the forces. To lose the camp and livestock aone would destroy the ability of the force to move, to lose the ammunition and supplies would be to lose the force. The "Defend the Camp" order was the reason for the loss of the men Pulleine never had enough men to achieve the task, though he possibly could have ensured the survival of some of his troops.

I am still of the view that reconnaissance in force to determine what the Zulu forces intentions were was the sensible thing to do given the "mindset" described above. If the whole force had been present instead of the most pwerful part conducting operations 12 miles away to no effect, we would be having a different discussion.
Sorry for the delay Tig,    Van broke down then one of my machines. Nightmare week thus far

Those 5,000 that moved behind Isandlwana were there to close the back door, and cause other sorts of grief, all Durnford done when he heard of it is to place a look out on top of Isandlwana, nothing after that, its then next mentioned by Melvill when its to late.

Durnfords purpose of moving Raw and Roberts to the valley beyond Mkwene was to sweep it from Zulus, and that is what the Zulu wanted.

Once the discovery was made there was only 15 minutes until they got to Mkwene its to late to strike the tents down.

Weather you do a recon or sweep the valley from Zulus it still requires men to leave the camp and that was the Zulu intention.

Craftiness is the best word to describe it.
Back to top Go down
Julian Whybra




Posts : 2862
Join date : 2011-09-12
Location : Billericay, Essex

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 12:11 pm

Aussie
"...that is what the Zulu wanted."
How can you possibly write this? There is no source describing what the Zulus wanted and they would have had no idea what Durnford would do once he'd arrived in camp - if, indeed, they even noticed he HAD arrived in camp. From their morning observations they would have realized that there were few mounted troops left in camp and any manoeuvring they did carry out could not possibly have been with the intention of 'luring out' the few such men who were there.
Back to top Go down
aussie inkosi

aussie inkosi


Posts : 371
Join date : 2013-09-16
Age : 56
Location : MELBOURNE

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 12:56 pm

Julian

There is no source describing what the Zulus wanted and they would have had no idea what Durnford would do once he'd arrived in camp
That is Why those 600 retired, Julian you are looking for sources the source is in the location of the discovery.

The Zulu saw Durnford enter the camp read Davies and then they devised a plan to get him to leave the camp.
Back to top Go down
Julian Whybra




Posts : 2862
Join date : 2011-09-12
Location : Billericay, Essex

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 1:50 pm

Aussie
"...the source is in the location of the discovery."  
As you well know, that is not a source; it is wishful thinking.  No historian worth his salt would endorse it.

"The Zulu saw Durnford enter the camp read Davies and then they devised a plan to get him to leave the camp."  
And that is pure supposition on your part.  We can't invent facts to order.


Last edited by Julian Whybra on Wed Mar 30, 2022 10:50 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top Go down
WeekendWarrior

WeekendWarrior


Posts : 230
Join date : 2017-07-21
Location : San Diego, CA

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 6:26 pm

I wonder if Durnford was actually Ntshingwayo in disguise.
Back to top Go down
aussie inkosi

aussie inkosi


Posts : 371
Join date : 2013-09-16
Age : 56
Location : MELBOURNE

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 9:00 pm

Julian
The reason no Historian has endorsed  its because they  still have the Zulu in the historical location, the facts are in the testimonies which have been interpreted incorrectly,

Julian , facts are Durnford responded to a Zulu retirement move, nothing can change that.

Its probably best I stop trying to convince anyone

The Zulu did such a great job that over 140 years after the fact it is still hidden
Back to top Go down
Julian Whybra




Posts : 2862
Join date : 2011-09-12
Location : Billericay, Essex

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 10:56 pm

"...facts are Durnford responded to a Zulu retirement move, nothing can change that."

Of course not, but that is not what you're trying to prove. You are wanting to say, as a fact, that the Zulu deliberately retired in the full knowledge that Durnford would chase after them. It isn't a fact and how could they possibly know what Durnford, or Pulleine come to that, would do (after all, the Zulus didn't know who had seniority). Indeed, they didn't know what orders LC had left for the camp.
Back to top Go down
aussie inkosi

aussie inkosi


Posts : 371
Join date : 2013-09-16
Age : 56
Location : MELBOURNE

James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 Empty
PostSubject: Re: James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance   James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance - Page 2 EmptyWed Mar 30, 2022 11:56 pm

PM you Julian
Back to top Go down
 
James Hamer testimony concerning time and distance
Back to top 
Page 2 of 2Go to page : Previous  1, 2
 Similar topics
-
» Quiz Time.......easy one this time.
» James Hamer (survivor of Isandlwana).
» James Hamer's letter to his Farther
» James Hamer life after iSandlwana
» Wagons at Isandlwana

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM  :: GENERAL DISCUSSION AREA-
Jump to: