isandlwana film

Subject: isandlwana film Sun Feb 20, 2011 8:45 pm

fistly, hi everyone this is my first post
just a thought...would anyone like to see a new film about the battle of isandlwana?
thoughts and observations would be good, not that i'm going to make it! :lol:

Posts : 1603 Join date : 2009-09-21

Hi. Bayonet Charge welcome to the forum

I would like to see a new film, but with the fiction taken out, and facture put in. Younghusband’s charge down the hill would be a must.

And keep Tom Cruise out!!!!!!!

Subject: Isandlwana Film Sun Feb 20, 2011 10:03 pm

Hi Bayonet Charge .
Firstly , welcome to the forum congrats on your first post . I along with everyone ( I would think everyone ! ) would certainly
wish to see a new film on Isandlwana , as Dave said Facts only , without the Tom Cruise effect !!!! . Dont mind Spielburg / Hanks
taking on the project .
cheers 90th Idea

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 6:53 am

Actually wouldnt mind seeing Tom Cruise with a sodding big spear sticking in him :lol!:

Posts : 600 Join date : 2010-01-07 Location : UK

Hi, Welcome to the forum, Personally what I wouldnt want to see is a a remake of Zulu, i think that they would just ruin the legend of Zulu.

An Isandlwana film i would love to see Idea

Joe

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 10:09 am

cheers for the welcome everyone. if they made this film well then Younghusband's charge down the hill could be a fantastic scene!

Posts : 747 Join date : 2009-10-18

Something like this.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 10:55 am

imagine that pic coming to life.

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 11:01 am

i wonder why the makers of Zulu Dawn didn't mention Younghusband's charge in the film. Had they just not heard of it or what?

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 11:21 am

Unfortunatly if it got into the hands of Hollywood it would end up like a scene from Brave heart, Bare a*****d covered in blue woad and shot in slow motion with every conceivable victorian melodramatic device attached.

I could imagine Colin Firth doing a good job of it though, provided he doesnt have to stutter that is.

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 11:28 am

springbok9 let's hope they do their research or let somebody who knows what they are doing have a go! Wink

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 3:04 pm

bayonet charge

Some one a tad more famous than me once said" Ah therin lays the rub". That could apply to this topic so eloquently. Who would be the somebody that knows.

There are so many, even in this age, divergent viewpoints that a movie would satisfy probably no more than 50% of the followers. Think about the potential clashes, an honest appraisal would see the Red Baron in a realy humiliating light, that would make the Chelmsford supporters ( both of them) rather unhappy.
Would we follow the Lock and Quantrill theory, there goes the Snook faction.
Middle of the road? Ian Knight? Greaves?

Really interesting to see who the forum members would have as say technical director/ playwright.

Probably the most knowledable would be a combination of Prof Laband and Ian Knight, but Snooks placing of the troops and the possible lines of retreat would have to be considered, even if his outright bias towards his regiment couldnt be.

A further thought, could the reputations of some key suvivors, Smith Dorean, Gardner, Essex, etc suvive an honest aproach?

More thought that goes in the more the topic gets interesting, nice one bayonet charge.

Regards

Subject: Re: isandlwana film Mon Feb 21, 2011 3:37 pm

cheers springbok9, i didn't quite give it as much thought as you are giving me credit for! :lol: but the way that a potential Isandlwana film is written, which characters it follows closely and whose historical records are followed make for an interesting discussion.

» Zulu Film Exhibition film now on You Tube
» Zulu - spot the mistakes
» From the film Zulu. Rubber-vest?