"It would take a week to make."

Guest

Hi all

Chelmsford did not see the need for the laager, stating, "It would take a week to make."

It is believed dreaming !

Cheers

Pascal

Guest

Qui ne dis rien,est d'accord Very Happy

Subject: Re: "It would take a week to make." Tue Dec 18, 2012 9:27 pm

The Lack Of Spades Didn't Help!

Guest

Yes that must be it ...

Subject: Re: "It would take a week to make." Tue Dec 18, 2012 11:17 pm

By Sir Henry Havelock.
"If the men at Isandula had had these light spades, they would have been able, even in a few hours, to have intrenched the camp, or, at any rate, to have thrown up a few rifle pits flanking each other. Then, with the powerful weapons with which our men were armed, he undertook to say that we should not now have been mourning a great disaster;"

Subject: It would take a week to make Tue Dec 18, 2012 11:51 pm

Hi Littlehand.
In all respect to Sir Henry Havelock , he wasnt there ! . As discussed previously many times there wasnt the manpower to prevent the Massacre .
90th

Subject: Re: "It would take a week to make." Wed Dec 19, 2012 12:49 am

We know 90th!!! . It was an observation,he felt needed to be made, in the house of commons to justify his allowance £££££ for attending. If he felt the battle was lost due to lack of light spades, then he's entilted to that opinion. The same as you are entitled to yours.

Quote :: "there wasnt the manpower to prevent the Massacre .90th

Guest

Hello Skippy

Everything held at the will of LC ...

If he had not despised Zulu, if he had not had undue reliance in the MH and if he had simply taken into account opinions of the old Boer ...

There would have been no massacre of the garrison camp, well entrenched it would have obtained the same results as the defenders of RD.

Cheers

Pascal

Subject: Re: "It would take a week to make." Wed Dec 19, 2012 7:36 pm

Isandlwana Probaly wouldn't have been selected. The hard ground would have still be the core issue of not being able to entrench.

Which leads me to a question.

If Isandlwana hadn't been selected, where would the next possible location have been?

Guest

The plateau at the foot of which was the Zulu army when she triggered the attack ...

The third column could occupy it, before the arrival of the impi...

The defense would have been facilitated

Posts : 2558 Join date : 2009-04-06 Age : 61 Location : UK

Good point, but then the Zulu's would have located themselves at Isandlwana.

Guest

The third column could occupy it, before the arrival of the impi...No ?

Subject: It would take a week to make Thu Dec 20, 2012 7:05 am

I know Littlehand !! . Havelock clearly had no right to make an assumption of any kind regarding the camp , he wasnt there , so couldn't / shouldn't have made any comment whatsoever about how light spades would save the day ! . Even though you say he made the comments to justify his pay ! . The bottom line is he spoke of something he had no idea of in any context whatsoever .
90th.

PS . Oh , and by the way, I think I'm more ( also many others on here ) qualified than Havelock to speak on this matter for the fact I / we do have 133 yrs of Hindsight and much information available to me as compared to him . If he or anyone thinks light spades would've saved the day then please go and read some literature on the battle . He is entitled to his own opinion as you say and so is anyone ,but lets face it he didnt have the evidence that we have today . Havelock wouldnt have been better advised to say nothing on the matter ! .

Guest

Hi Gary

If Havelock had no right to do so ...

We no longer then ...

Cheers

Pascal

Subject: It would take a week to make Thu Dec 20, 2012 7:19 am

Pascal .
You dont understand my post ! . Read it again !! . We have 133 yrs of evidence to look at , he had nothing compared to what we have to look at !! . Shocked

Hopefully you will read my post again and understand it ! . Shocked

.
90th

Guest

Yes Sir

Subject: It would take a week to make Thu Dec 20, 2012 7:33 am

Pascal .
At ease , Soldier ! Salute

90th.

Guest

soldier Gary, guard you Salute

Posts : 2593 Join date : 2009-04-24

Quote :: I know Littlehand !! . Havelock clearly had no right to make an assumption of any kind regarding the camp , he wasnt there , so couldn't / shouldn't have made any comment whatsoever about how light spades would save the day ! . Even though you say he made the comments to justify his pay ! . The bottom line is he spoke of something he had no idea of in any context whatsoever .

90th perhaps he was told.

Posts : 2593 Join date : 2009-04-24

Quote :: I know Littlehand !! . Havelock clearly had no right to make an assumption of any kind regarding the camp , he wasnt there , so couldn't / shouldn't have made any comment whatsoever about how light spades would save the day ! . Even though you say he made the comments to justify his pay ! . The bottom line is he spoke of something he had no idea of in any context whatsoever .

90th perhaps he was told.

Guest

yes, maybe scratch

Subject: It would take a week to make Thu Dec 20, 2012 8:48 am

Hi Ctsg.
Possibly that was the case . Who knows , but without merit all the same .
Cheers 90th.

Guest

Yes Gary, perhaps he was told.

» What do you make of this.
» The ammunition question
» Did any of the other officer’s make critical mistakes.