WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM

Film Zulu: (Michael Caine) If 1200 men couldn't hold a defensive position this morning, what chance have we with 100?
 
HomeHome  GalleryGallery  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
Latest topics
» Officers at Ulundi
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyToday at 2:14 am by 90th

» Possible Zulu war medal holder and family.
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue May 04, 2021 5:12 pm by gardner1879

» Orderly Room Sergeant role
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySun May 02, 2021 7:17 pm by jancodk

» Melvill's Revolver Cylinder
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySat May 01, 2021 6:58 pm by Julian Whybra

» Colour - Sergeant George William Mabin
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySat May 01, 2021 6:15 pm by Visitor

» The Passing of Her Majesty Queen Mantfombi Dlamini Zulu.
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Apr 30, 2021 9:37 am by ADMIN

» Ian Knight Questions and answers
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 29, 2021 11:51 pm by aussie inkosi

» Sir Henry Bartle Frere letter to Sir Henry Ponsonby
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 29, 2021 6:39 pm by gardner1879

» Boy 1st Class Thomas Harris
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySun Apr 25, 2021 6:19 pm by RickB

» Gabangaye - was he ubidied?
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Apr 23, 2021 2:43 pm by Julian Whybra

» List of identified bodies at Isandlwana
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 22, 2021 8:26 pm by Frank Allewell

» 1595 Pte. E. Jones 2/24th
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 22, 2021 10:40 am by RickB

» New British Muzleloaders videos on Isandlwana
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyWed Apr 21, 2021 3:33 pm by Frank Allewell

» Library destroyed
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Apr 20, 2021 5:42 am by barry

» Zulu War Medal
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySat Apr 17, 2021 4:38 pm by Bill8183

» sergeant G J Brown
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySat Apr 17, 2021 12:10 pm by 90th

» Captain HUGH O'DONNELL.
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Apr 16, 2021 7:32 pm by WeekendWarrior

» Great Grandfather James (Jimmy) Robinson DCM
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Apr 16, 2021 3:54 pm by Kenny

» In Affectionate Remembrance of P.C. Stephens
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Apr 16, 2021 1:36 pm by gardner1879

» Trpr. Simpson's medal
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 08, 2021 5:13 pm by Julian Whybra

» Someone maybe able to help. 2235 Pte A F Edmonds J7th DCOLrg
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 08, 2021 3:30 am by 90th

» Medal ribbon on Patrol Jacket
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySun Apr 04, 2021 9:47 pm by John Young

» One of the lesser-known stories. It took place around the same time as Isandlwana.
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySun Apr 04, 2021 9:54 am by Julian Whybra

» Isandlwana Survivor photo's
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySat Apr 03, 2021 7:06 pm by ADMIN

» <Pte. W. Dunne 2nd Btn 3rd (East Kent) Regiment ('The Buffs') & Sgt. O. Hydenburg (Aydenburg) Natal Native Contingent,)
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Apr 02, 2021 1:33 pm by gardner1879

» William Papworth. Alan Gardner's servant.
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 01, 2021 10:28 pm by gardner1879

» Smith-Dorrien 1881
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyThu Apr 01, 2021 5:45 pm by John Young

» Archibald Forbes query
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Mar 30, 2021 11:26 am by Julian Whybra

» Norris-Newman
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Mar 29, 2021 10:17 am by ADMIN

» Forum questions or problems!
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySun Mar 28, 2021 10:25 pm by ADMIN

» Pte Lewitt of the 58th Foot
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySun Mar 28, 2021 12:09 am by 90th

» nTshingwayo ka Mahole
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Mar 26, 2021 6:07 am by Frank Allewell

» George Astell Pardoe Lieutentant, 13th Light Infantry
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyWed Mar 24, 2021 12:13 am by 90th

» Press coverage of the Zulu King
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Mar 22, 2021 9:33 am by Frank Allewell

» Mini Series : Shaka: King of the Zulu Nation
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptySat Mar 20, 2021 9:47 am by Frank Allewell

Search
 
 

Display results as :
 
Rechercher Advanced Search
Rorke's Drift to the British Museum: Story of Henry Hook
Top posters
90th
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Frank Allewell
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
littlehand
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
ADMIN
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
1879graves
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
rusteze
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Chelmsfordthescapegoat
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
John
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Mr M. Cooper
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Julian Whybra
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Top posting users this month
gardner1879
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
John Young
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
90th
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Visitor
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
1879graves
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
jancodk
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Frank Allewell
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Julian Whybra
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
ADMIN
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Peter35
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_leftTop points of disagreement between historians/authors BarTop points of disagreement between historians/authors Bar_right 
Most active topics
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
Durnford was he capable.1
Isandlwana, Last Stands
Durnford was he capable.5
Durnford was he capable. 4
The ammunition question
Durnford was he capable. 3
Durnford was he capable.2
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.
Most Viewed Topics
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
The missing five hours.
Isandlwana, Last Stands
Adding to the Library
The ammunition question
Recent Members To The ZULU WAR 1879 Discussion & Reference Forum ( A Small Victorian War in 1879)
ISANDLWANA SURVIVIORS
Durnford was he capable.5
Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
Lieutenant Adendorff 1-3 N.N.C.
Fair Use Notice
Fair use notice. This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner. We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website. If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution.
Keywords
carbineers George henry Russell taylor Isandlwana drift Franklin Police Forbes john harford martini Woolfryes payne smith horse zulu Natal james Mounted spalding melvill Durnford 24th Prince
 

 Top points of disagreement between historians/authors

Go down 
AuthorMessage
dlancast

dlancast

Posts : 42
Join date : 2010-11-05
Location : Texas

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 5:24 pm

I was wondering what forum members consider the top ten(not to limit the list) points are that historians/authrors seem to disagree on in the AZW.  I know that I have 70 - 80 books, articles etc and smetimes it is confusing to get at the real truth of the matter (if that is even possible).  Some examples might be
* Was Chelmsford lured out?
* Where did the main Impi stay the night before the battle?
* What do you think?
Back to top Go down
John Young

John Young

Posts : 2250
Join date : 2013-09-08
Age : 65
Location : Lower Sheering, Essex

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 5:33 pm

dlancast,

There's the old chestnut of the ammunition supply to the firing-line.

The number of European survivors of iSandlwana is still a bone of contention for some.

The number of the garrison at Rorke's Drift, obviously including who was/was not there.

Just a few for starters.

JY
Back to top Go down
littlehand

littlehand

Posts : 7077
Join date : 2009-04-24
Age : 52
Location : Down South.

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 7:02 pm

M&C is another!  Along with the VC question?
Back to top Go down
24th

24th

Posts : 1857
Join date : 2009-03-25

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 7:24 pm

Was David Jenkins at RD:suspect: 
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 7:48 pm


Was David Jenkins at RD Suspect 

24th, not long now, we can wait
another four day's, look forward
to your counter view's.
Neutral  cheers xhosa
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 7:59 pm

Carey and Harvard.
who bungled at
Hlobane. how much
cattle was actually
' lifted ' who got
what?..
Back to top Go down
kopie



Posts : 249
Join date : 2013-06-01

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 8:06 pm

I would like to chip in with one or two fairly obvious and long argued disagreements.

1. Was Chelmsford right right to split his force prior to Isandhlwana?

2. Was the loss of Isandhlwana Chelmsford's fault? Or was it Durnford's fault?

3. Did Lord Chelmsford scapegoat a dead man (Durnford) for the loss of Isandhlwana in order to save his own neck?
Back to top Go down
impi

impi

Posts : 2308
Join date : 2010-07-02
Age : 41

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 11:39 pm

Did the Zulus really intend to attack on the 23rd Jan.


Why did Chelmsford really stop Harness from moving to the camp ?




Why did Chelmsford want Harness on the panel of the court of enquiry ? 
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyFri Nov 01, 2013 11:52 pm

impi.yes! Very Happy  could fill the page with a lot
of these Suspect  question was the
' cover up ' a pre thought contingency
stratagem. Hmmm. xhosa
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Nov 04, 2013 4:19 am

dlancast wrote: ".... confusing to get at the real truth of the matter (That is if even possible)."

This is true dlancast, the more you read, the less you know, because like many other battles, 99% of authors copy each other ...

Not counting, the authors having written of the .....

You just have to read the books of Messrs. David Jackson and Julian Whybra and thou shalt make savings of time and money by being as close to the truth ...

Cheers

Pascal

Back to top Go down
24th

24th

Posts : 1857
Join date : 2009-03-25

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Nov 04, 2013 8:41 pm

Ian Knight's books would be the best bet!
Back to top Go down
Chelmsfordthescapegoat

Chelmsfordthescapegoat

Posts : 2581
Join date : 2009-04-24

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Nov 04, 2013 9:16 pm

Admin. Can we stop this dropping of authors names, and who writes the best books. Looking historically the only thing this achieves is bringing discussions to a halt. Use their material to base an argument, but not to score brownie points. John young, never pluggs his book, he just joins in the discussions and produces excellent photographs. There are no books out there that can tell us what happen at Isandlwana. We already know. Jackson's maybe the best to some, but his book can't tell us anything other books can't. 

Springboks app, gives a better overview of the battlefield and who was where, than any book I have!
Back to top Go down
ymob

ymob

Posts : 2268
Join date : 2010-10-22
Location : France

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Nov 04, 2013 10:24 pm



Springboks app, gives a better overview of the battlefield and who was where, than any book I have![/quote]
Bonsoir,
Maybe, YOU haven't got the " Best" books? Very Happy 
( no offense for Springboks).
Cheers.
Frédéric
Back to top Go down
http://frbomy@hotmail.fr
littlehand

littlehand

Posts : 7077
Join date : 2009-04-24
Age : 52
Location : Down South.

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Nov 04, 2013 10:32 pm

Ymob  Which one would you recommend. I would be interesting in one that gives photographic views of the battlefield, with a detailed overview of what took place at that particular point.
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyMon Nov 04, 2013 11:17 pm

cstg, just curious, but are you a book
collector? there is no reason, of course
why you should be, your sources are as
valid as any, but fredric's repost made
me smile,then wonder. cheers xhosa
Back to top Go down
ymob

ymob

Posts : 2268
Join date : 2010-10-22
Location : France

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Nov 05, 2013 1:39 am

I would be interesting in one that gives photographic views of the battlefield, with a detailed overview of what took place at that particular point.[/quote]


Bonsoir Littlehand,

For the battle of Isandhlwana, I am agree with "Chelsmfordthescapegoat", "Springboks" can made this sort of books -Seriously.
One day, it seems to me that Springbok had said that he is writing "a different book" on this battle...
There is on the web, a "free" site that gives many photographic views of the battlefield and describes what took place at that particular point (with only few errors). Sorry, at this moment, i don't recall the link.
For me, there is not "this sort of book" specific on the battle of Isandhlwana.
On this subject, il only have a copy of "sort of guidebook" to the AZW battlefields as:
"The illustraded guide to the AZW" by John Laband and Paul Thompson;
"Then and Now" by Ian Knight;
"Guidebook to the AZW battlefields" by David Rattray;
-Two booklets: "Isandlwana" and "Rorke's Drift" by Ian Knight and Ian Castle (collection: Battleground south africa).

For "books" (and not essay) on the battle of Isandhlwana, it's a very delicate question (and answer).
- "The Hill of the Sphinx" by FWD Jackson (academic research);
-Zulu Rising"(and the "silver book" for the photos) by Ian Knight ;
-For the "debate": "Zulu victory" by Ron Lock and Peter Quantrill;
- For the "fiction": (no offense)"How can men ..." by Mike Snook and "The washing of the spears" by Morris.

After, they are books interesting on "specific point"of the battle of Isandhlwana:
-On the losses and survivors: Whybra, Young, Holme;
- On the Zulu: Laband-Knight-Smith...
- On the NNC:Thompson-Smith...
- On Durnford:Drooglever, Snook...
- On the 24th : Gon...
- On Chelsmford- Laband...
- On the NMP: Holt;
- On diaries, journals or comtemporary sources: HARFORD, HAMILTON BROWNE, NEWHAM-DAVIS, HALLAM-PARR, CURLING, SMITH-DORRIEN, (MOODIE, EMERY)...
- etc....
I suppose Sonia Clarke is a very good author (two books too expansive for me!!!).
It's just an opinion.


Cheers.

Frédéric
Back to top Go down
http://frbomy@hotmail.fr
Frank Allewell

Frank Allewell

Posts : 7749
Join date : 2009-09-21
Age : 74
Location : Cape Town South Africa

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Nov 05, 2013 6:03 am

Theres a couple of different ways of looking at the Battlefields.
1)For the person who wants to know the battlefield and where everything took place in chronological order with effectively a diorama. Then the more photos and maps the better.

2)Then there is the more serious/studious that wants to know WHY not Where. The minutae of decisions, who made them, why they were made.

3)Then there are the speculative who attempt to find solutions to fit the puzzles.

The books that are often quoted can be slotted into those categories. My app was born out of this forum and the numbers of members that wont ever get to the battlefields and so need a more visual picture of the events. I would therefore fit into the first category I suppose. As would Ian Knights: Then and Now and the various battlefield guides.

For the second, there are the really serious publications from Whybra, Jackson, Knight Smith et al.

The third would encompass the likes of Snook Quantrill etc.

Every one of those 3 are important in trying to get a view of this bloody battle. But I don't believe you can compare one section with another, they all fill a void.

Ymob
No offence taken mate. Salute 
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Nov 05, 2013 8:22 am

Everyone's opinion, but to save time and money, and I always say to those who say contacts me, or come see to my hordes of figures, if they want to imitate me or if they simply are interested by the Zulu war, they must purchase priority "Hill of the Sphinx" and all that Julian has published, so they save time and money ...

I show them these books and when they see that they are in, they all regret all their purchases of precedents books on this war ...

After having contacted me, like many, they realize that they have put the cart before the horse ...

This is where it ends ...

Regarding color photos ... Too bad there is not have to get the possibility of color pictures in 1879 ...

We could compare them with those made in XX and XXI th centuries, still a good opportunity to laugh ...

This is where it ends ...

Pascal
Back to top Go down
ymob

ymob

Posts : 2268
Join date : 2010-10-22
Location : France

Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Nov 05, 2013 10:59 am

Ymob
No offence taken mate.
Salute [/quote] 
 
 
Bonjour Springbok,
 
No problem for me...and I am totally agree with you!!!
And your project of a "different book" on the battle of Isandhlwana?
 
Cheers.
 
Frédéric
Back to top Go down
http://frbomy@hotmail.fr
Guest
Guest



Top points of disagreement between historians/authors Empty
PostSubject: Re: Top points of disagreement between historians/authors   Top points of disagreement between historians/authors EmptyTue Nov 05, 2013 3:08 pm

In fact color photos on the battlefields in Zululand, there are plenty on the internet ...

No utilities except for the South African tourism, because the battlefields of 1879, should no longer have great things to do with photos taken at the end of the twentieth century and the XXIst century...
Back to top Go down
 
Top points of disagreement between historians/authors
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
WWW.1879ZULUWAR.COM  :: GENERAL DISCUSSION AREA-
Jump to: