Isandlwana Survivor Medal

Subject: Isandlwana Survivor Medal Sat Nov 22, 2014 3:06 am

For those who might be interested ....Sergio ??????? . Bit to rich for me

http://www.dnw.co.uk/auctions/catalogue/lot.php?auction_id=323&lot_id=836

If you read the 5th paragraph in the Footnote section it will create more questions than answers , quite possibly the two have been confused ???
Cheers 90th

Posts : 947 Join date : 2011-10-21 Location : Algoa Bay

Hi 90th,
Hope all is well downunder.
Agreed, the price of that medal is exhorbitant and the seller is a chancer. Overpricing by some 5 fold
The damaged and repaired suspension takes the value down too.
I seriously question their "citation" too as they were unable to spell ; ; ie Dumford, Pullin, Dinckleman, IsandHlwana, Matitzburg and Double Mountain? etc, etc, the question is begged : what else did they get wrong?.

regards

barry

Posts : 269 Join date : 2010-12-02 Location : Kloof, KZN

90th

Thanks for posting this link. I have been looking for a Newcastle Mounted Rifles medal for a long time, but specifically one to a man who was with Major Dartnell on his patrol. I already have such medals to the Natal Mounted Police, Natal Carbineers, and Buffalo Border Guard, and one to the NMR would complete the set to the mounted Colonial element on the Dartnell patrol. In theory at least, such medals are a lot less expensive than those to men killed in action and the escapers. Also in theory, there should be 21 medals to the NMR who were on patrol.

Regards
Brett

Subject: Isandlwana Survivor Medal Sat Nov 22, 2014 10:37 am

Hi Barry
Yes mate all is well here , hopefully it's going well for you also ? . I wouldnt be surprised if the medal goes for nearly what an Imperial Casualty would bring ! . It's indeed a rare medal and unit to have . I've been a bit over the top recently , so dont have the Ammo to launch an assault on it , although I'd like to have it in my collection Shocked

Hi Brett
Your collection sounds very interesting , I'm intrigued as to the details of your collection . Feel free to send me a pm regarding your collection and I'll do likewise with mine if you wish ? . Salute

Cheers 90th

Subject: Isandlwana Survivor Medal Sat Nov 22, 2014 10:42 am

I also forgot to mention the DNW Auction also has two Isandlwana Casualty Medals , will be interesting to see what price they bring ? Shocked

90th

Subject: Re: Isandlwana Survivor Medal Mon Nov 24, 2014 11:10 am

Hi 90th

yes I saw this medal and was excited at first glance , But was put off by the state of it , broached and reconstituted.

The question of value vs a casualty is interesting. IS their more worth in a medal that was handed to to a relative - vs a medal that was touched and worn with pride by someone who actually witnessed, fought and survived the battle.

Its an interesting debate. I saw the other casualty medals - but have my eye on a nice couple of Abu Klea pairs so not for me this auction.

However, the Colonel Collingwood group is interesting -I might have a cheeky bid on it but suspect it will price outside my budget if I am successful in the Abu Kleas

http://www.dnw.co.uk/auctions/catalogue/lot.php?auction_id=323&lot_id=156&backto=cabinet

Cheers

Sergio

Subject: Isandlwana Survivor Medal Mon Nov 24, 2014 11:51 am

Hi Sergio
Certainly an interesting group the ' Collingwood ' I wont be playing in this auction . Have to save up for the next Zulu Land Tour .
90th Shocked

» Original Queen South African Medal Zulu War medal
» isandlwana survivor medal to Hamer sold today
» South Africa Medal and 1877-8-9 Bar with India General Service Medal and Burma 1887-1889 Bar (1492 Pte G Adams, 2/24th Foot and 2nd Battalion, S Wales Borderers)
» Baltic Medal & South Africa Medal (1879), William King, HMS Exmouth & Boadicea
» Col sgt Bourne Medal Group. Including Zulu War Campaign Medal