IS there any thing left to write about DELETED.

Posts : 94 Join date : 2009-02-13

This topic has been deleted. Please note personal attacks will not be tolerated.
This site has been set up to allow members to have friendly discussions in connection with the Anglo Zulu War.

DTSG. I don't think it is necessary for you in particular, to bring Col: Mike Snook into your discussions. which you seemed to have a habit of doing.

Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 43

Totally agree with thread deletion. Idea

Posts : 94 Join date : 2009-02-13

I accept the deletion about the Col.
I really do not want to get into a discussion about his book.
I wanted to ask about whether or not there is any new avenue of research open into the AZW.
Most of us obviously have our opinions about what happened and these have been much discussed.
It seems to me that all the primary sources are out there.
There does not appear to be any new diaries or maps or reports still undiscovered.
Archeology seems to be unhelpful
There is a book on espionage in the AZW which I think is a topic that has not been covered in the past.
Are there any other such "angles" for new research?

Hi,
I personally think there's probably a lot more to discover in many aspects about the Zulu War. Looking forward to future books about the battle of Hlobane.

I agree. But I think nothing else can be written about Isandlwana that we don't already know. Unless Crealocks Diary was found,

Remains were found last year, and identified.
So look at a couple of what ifs.
What if Pulleins body was found?
What if substantial remains were found on the ridge?
What if an officers buttons were found on the trail?

Wnen Twots was published it was regarded as the definitive work answering all questions, we now know thats not true. Slow chipping away of fact from fiction, small pieces in the puzzle. Still lots of questions still to be asked.

Regards

Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 43

With regards to the "Button" that was found. The owner of that button as not been identified as yet. Bit lost on what if an officers button was found on the trail. It was mostly officers that fled via the trail.

Im pretty sure that the owner of the buttom has been identified.

As to finding a button on the trail, it could point to Smiths Grave. Also there have been one or two references to an officer on a white horse, never really identified.

My point being that the battlefields still have more secrets to reveal, possibly?

Posts : 2594 Join date : 2009-04-24

Quote :: Im pretty sure that the owner of the buttom has been identified.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Thank you CTSG.
Says it all really, theres very little doubt who it is.

Again the point being that there is still lots to think and talk and argue about

Regards

Posts : 2594 Join date : 2009-04-24

AMAFA were wrongly criticised for their part in not doing what some of the Brits would have liked them do to. (Be it not really nothing to do with the Brits) to be honest if we never found out whom the soldier was I wouldn’t blame AMAFA in the slightest.

They got a raw deal from some rather insignificant people puffed up with there own importance............have a feeling thats going to get me into trouble.

Regards

Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 43

Interesting last post. Doe's the British have an opinion on how the Anglo Zulu War Battlefields are care for. Or is it really nothing to do with them. The photo's I have seen of Isandlwana tells me they are well looked after and respected. We may hear of the odd bit of damage, but no more that we get back home. Do the British contribute directly into the up keep or indirectly through donations ect.

Posts : 629 Join date : 2009-01-20 Age : 45

Quote :: Do the British contribute directly into the up keep or indirectly through donations ect.

Ken. Would be the best person to answer this.

Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25

AMAFA. What doe's it stand for.

Hi
Regarding Isandlwana, I will never get tired on reading books about the battle. Although, as I've said before in my earlier post, Hlobane remains my favourite. As long as great authors like, Ian Knight, Ron Lock & Peter Quantrill, also Mike Snook, who incidentley captivated the closing stages of Isandlwana superbly, continue to write about this fascinating subject, then I will continue to purchase their work. It's their writing style that draw's you in, and lets you into another world. That's their talent, and also, it keeps this extremely exciting subject alive & kicking for our generation, and the next. Rock on!!!

Posts : 420 Join date : 2011-05-14

24th,

Amafa is Zulu for bequest; inheritance; legacy.

The full name is Amafa aKwaZulu Natalai.

kwaJimu1879

AMAFA is Heritage

Regards

Posts : 94 Join date : 2009-02-13

I think we South Africans do a pretty good job of preserving our battlefields thank you very much.
I see there have been incidents of vandalization of war graves in Normandy and the Somme yet you do not get prophets of doom going on about how things are going to the dogs.

» Topic Deleted. Martin Everett - Curator SWB museum, Brecon. Arrogant? Or chip on his shoulder?
» Why were soldiers left at Rorkes Drift,
» A curious thing! Say's Henry Hook.
» Durnford left the Donga at the hight of the battle??
» Saluting Left handed?