Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records

Guest

Hi Jimu

What I write in Breton? And what Breton dialect, there are 8 Breton dialect ! Generally I write in "Frenchglish" and everyone understands! Very Happy

ES ? Is that he did not understand! Very Happy

Posts : 420 Join date : 2011-05-14

Pascal,

Mat an traoù ganit?

Lavar-se en-dro, mar plij

Pascal wrote:: ES ? Is that he did not understand!

Yes it was!

It is Frenglish by the way! Joker

Devezh vat deoc'h

'Jimu

Guest

The Frengish is a convenient language, and in Brittany, there is also the "Englench" when a British want to speak Breton or French Very Happy

Posts : 110 Join date : 2013-06-16

24th

Chard says a Private Jenkins saved his life, if it wasn't David then who was it ?

The guy who was dead or dying in his hospital bed ?

Of course the problem will always be, those who say he was there, can't prove. And those who say he wasn't can't prove it! Question

Guest

The 1/24 th Foot at Rorke's Drift :

25/56 Sergeant Edward Wilson
25B/135 Private William Beckett Patient's hospital
25B/568 Private Patrick Desmond
1-24/1861 Private William Horrigan Patient's hospital
25B/295 Private David Jenkins
25B/841 Private James Jenkins Patient's hospital
25B/625 Private Edward Nicholas Patient's hospital
25/B372 Private Thomas Payton
1-24/1542 Private William Roy Patient's hospital
25B/104 Private Henry Turner
1-24/447 Private John Waters

Firstly: None of these patients above, are war wounded of the January 12, 1879 battle, they are all sick.

Secondly :On the January 12, 1879... After taking the village of Sihayo, the third column is left with 10 Zulu prisoners intact and 4 zulu wounded and also prisoners .also except the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins ,who escorted the prisoners on the list above, where and when?, those who were not sick were part of the escort ?

Thirdly : You know the total number of men of this escort ,except the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins of which units, these men were and And what is their date of arrival at destination?

Fourthly : I do not understand that the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins remained in RD that has no sense!

Cheers

PTR

Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25

Pascal MAHE wrote:: The 1/24 th Foot at Rorke's Drift :

25/56 Sergeant Edward Wilson
25B/135 Private William Beckett Patient's hospital
25B/568 Private Patrick Desmond
1-24/1861 Private William Horrigan Patient's hospital
25B/295 Private David Jenkins
25B/841 Private James Jenkins Patient's hospital
25B/625 Private Edward Nicholas Patient's hospital
25/B372 Private Thomas Payton
1-24/1542 Private William Roy Patient's hospital
25B/104 Private Henry Turner
1-24/447 Private John Waters

Firstly: None of these patients above, are war wounded of the January 12, 1879 battle, they are all sick.

Secondly :On the January 12, 1879... After taking the village of Sihayo, the third column is left with 10 Zulu prisoners intact and 4 zulu wounded and also prisoners .also except the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins ,who escorted the prisoners on the list above, where and when?, those who were not sick were part of the escort ?

Thirdly : You know the total number of men of this escort ,except the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins of which units, these men were and And what is their date of arrival at destination?

Fourthly : I do not understand that the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins remained in RD that has no sense!
Cheers PTR

Good to see you asking the right questions. Should have posted this in the "Jenkins Topic"

Guest

24 th

It is not whether or not if the 25B/295 Private David Jenkins was or not at RD , that interested me but it's the 1/24 th in the battle of RD and the "why" of the comings and goings of some men of this brave battalion between Zululand and Natal between 12 January 1879 and 22 January 1879... Very Happy

Cheers

Pascal the Wink

Pascal, it makes sense to merge this with the Pte Jenkins topic, as you mention him in points 2 3 & 4 and it seems relevant to the discussion in hand. Salute

Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44

Old Julian's taking his time with his publication. Rolling Eyes

I guess it must be a struggle looking for something that doesn't exist. Rolling Eyes

Guest

It does not take time to look for something that does not exist, it's in the bag (from the beginning) and you will see that the end of August or early September Very Happy

Posts : 1603 Join date : 2009-09-21

I'm hoping Impi is incorrect when he says, it will be information we have seen or already know about, but re-worded. And not just a load of what if's.

Guest

LOL Impi is completely wrong and you will understand when you read the next issue of Julian !

Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25

I'm fairly confident that Julian wouldn't say something he could do if he couldn't. It wouldn't do his reputation as an Historian any good. I just hope its not just about those old ledgers in the museum.

Guest

In general ,it only says that it can prove !

I'm doubt it really matters what Julian publishes , as I think some have made up their minds and may not want to change their views .
90th.

Posts : 747 Join date : 2009-10-18

In which case, is he not wasting his time. I prefer to get as much information as possible before deciding.

Subject: Pte David Jenkins Forgotten survivor of RD . Tue Aug 06, 2013 12:20 pm

I doubt Julian thinks he's wasting his time , but as I said , I think some on here will think he's wasted his time . We will see when the time comes wont we ! .
90th

Guest

I'm doubt it really matters what Publishes Julian, as I think some Have Made Up Their Minds and May not want to change Their views.

It is their right Marsy, but I think they are just two ...

Guest

All which in case, he is not wasting His time. I prefer to get as much information as possible, before Deciding.

It is your right Mr Greavy, Like this, and you will be just three ...

Subject: Pte David Jenkins Tue Aug 06, 2013 1:21 pm

Have no fear, Julian is not wasting his time, and all those of you that have abused and 'had a bash' at Julian and doubted if Pte David Jenkins was at RD, will hopefully get a very rude awakening when Julian 'comes up with the goods' and produces 'the evidence'.

Guest

I doubt Julian thinks he's wasting His time, I order you said, I think some on here Will think he's wasted His time. We will see When the time comes we wont! .

Yes Marsy , it will be quite a headlock for Julian

Guest

Marty LOL LOL LOL

Posts : 558 Join date : 2012-05-05

Is a case of rude awakening or headlock. I think not! It just goes to show that some people are willing to accept what they are told to accept, because others say so.

Then there are others who seek alittle more, before they accept it as fact, if that is the case. I don't think JW is doing this to get an apology, he is doing to set the record straight. The poll was a close run thing, that showed what I have said above.

Guest

There is only one chance in a million, it is wrong Very Happy

Ulundi
Well done, pretty close to the truth. Julian has a much wider audience than this forum ( sorry Pete no offence intended ). And his research is done as a profesion, not as an emotive issue.
One things for sure he does not take chances such as a number of other researchers/authors are known to do. His research is pretty solid and if a mistake occurs he is the first to acknowledge.

Lets wait and see shall we.

Cheers

Guest

Very good

Guest

Of course Julian's record speaks
for its self.i listen attentively..
when he speaks.i dont see many
others rushing around doing this
research which must be so time
consuming,and all for our better
understanding.he's a top bloke.
regards xhosa2000

Hi Les
Probably not well known but all the profits from the sales of his essays/papers sold through the Brecon Museum go towards the upkeep of the museum.

PS did you get to the cricket?

Guest

Hiya Gary,yes i know that about Julian.iv'e got all
his published stuff,iv'e been following him for years
Hi Julian. the thing that i like about him is extraordinary
patience,he cant help himself he just has to get the
information out..

Yeah went on the fourth day.and i say to anybody dont
write the Aussies off.they have a bit of momentum at
the mo. but i think pound for pound,were the better side.

any sign of you know what yet. cheers mate Les.

Guest

Poor Julian, late August / early September, he will have to be even fencing on 50 pages to convince skeptics...

Hi Les
Nothing as yet, the runner with the forked stick still being chased by the odd Lion or so.
i will let you know soon as it does show.

Cheers

Hi Les .
Yes , the mail arrived ! Very Happy

. I tried them and they seem fine , will watch them later . Again thanks , much appreciated .
Cheers 90th. agree

Guest

I dont know Julian personally he has been
good enough to point me in the right
direction, and always with good humour
and patience.but this thread makes me
wonder, how many of his armchair critics
have actually produced ANYTHING to further
our better understanding of this fascinating
chapter of british history..no axe to grind..
but like iv'e said i have been watching this
site for years before i jumped in ( with a big
intentional splash.)

All you trolls remember.."The Horn's of the
Buffalo". ( that was a stratagem.)

His continuing research enriches our better
understanding.and even on a basic level we
all DESERVE respect. cheers xhosa2000

Posts : 2268 Join date : 2010-10-22 Location : France

Bonsoir xhosa2000

Totally agree.

Regard

Frederic

Guest

Hiya. frederic,thank you.Les.

Guest

90th.no problem.you and springbok was first.
regards xhosa2000

Hi xhosa

Guest

When the soldier Whybra will come back, he'll catch a good headache ...LOL LOL LOL

springbok9 wrote:: Hi Les
Probably not well known but all the profits from the sales of his essays/papers sold through the Brecon Museum go towards the upkeep of the museum.

PS did you get to the cricket?

I see springbok was the culprit? Sneaking this in. Suspect

Guest

Soz admin

Posts : 30 Join date : 2010-01-14

From the Cambrian, c. March 1905

Hero of Rorke's Drift

Sergeant Henry Hook VC, formerly of the South Wales Borderers, died at Gloucester on Sunday, age 54. Deceased, who won his Victoria Cross in the Defence of Rorke's Drift, was attendant at the British Museum for twenty years, and recently retired owing to ill health, his Victoria Cross pension of £10 being increased to £50 by the War Office.
The cause of death was consumption. He leaves a widow and two little daughters.
SWANSEA VETERAN RECALLS HIM.
Mr David Jenkins, who is employed at the Swansea Corporation Yard, is a survivor of the historic Rorke's Drift fight, and to him a 'Post' man repaired on Monday.
"Oh, yes," responded the ex-24th hero; "I remember Hook well; but he was not in my battalion. I was in the 1st, and he was a private in the 'B' Company of the second 24th. I recollect now," continued the veteran, reflectively, "that he was on the roof doing his bit towards keeping off the Zulus. We had, as you know, 27 out of 128 killed, but accounted for over 800 of the enemy. No, he wasn't wounded; but he got his VC all right, and well he deserved it. A quiet fellow, but a good fighter. But, there, we all had to fight."

Posts : 2558 Join date : 2009-04-06 Age : 61 Location : UK

Was "Hook" on the roof at one point? I thought he was inside the hospital and from there to the wall. And " Hook" was wounded forehead wound!

All
Thirty years later Jenkins has clearly confused Hook with Hitch.
All
I will not be hurried by those ignorant of the process of research, writing, obtaining permissions under copyright laws, and the process of printing and proof-reading. When I write I like it to be perfect and unassailable. I am currently on target, as I said weeks ago, for publication sometime between the end of August and mid-September. When the doc goes to the printers I'll let you know and as soon as it's generally available I'll let you know.
Impi
Have your knife and fork ready.

Guest

Good evening Julian,will wait for your
upcoming output with due anticipation.
how many vols do expect to publish.i
understand you have lots and lots of
material to organize and then finally
distribute.

Custom made slip cases might have
to be considered. cheers xhosa2000.

Posts : 30 Join date : 2010-01-14

One more for the pot !

from South Wales Daily Post, July 1900

"Ex-Private Jenkins, of Swansea, one of the heroic defenders of Rorke's Drift, and who it will be remembered sat for Lady Butler's famous picture of that title, has received the following letter from Lady Butler, Government House, Devonport, July 15th, 1900.-
'Sir-, In answer to your enquiry I write to say that my picture of 'Rorke's Drift' has never been engraved, otherwise I would long ago have had the pleasure of sending you an artist's proof in recognition of the great pains you took with the sittings you gave me for that picture. Hoping you are well, I remain, yours very truly, Elizabeth Butler.'
Ex-Private Jenkins is at present employed as storekeeper by the Swansea Corporation."

Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44

Julian Whybra wrote:: All
Thirty years later Jenkins has clearly confused Hook with Hitch.
All
I will not be hurried by those ignorant of the process of research, writing, obtaining permissions under copyright laws, and the process of printing and proof-reading. When I write I like it to be perfect and unassailable. I am currently on target, as I said weeks ago, for publication sometime between the end of August and mid-September. When the doc goes to the printers I'll let you know and as soon as it's generally available I'll let you know.
Impi
Have your knife and fork ready.

We are talking August- Mid- September this year?
Wasn't Hitch wounded. Rolling Eyes

Sherman. The letter is merely pointing that Jenkins sat for Lady Bulers painting. Most of the RD defenders were overseas and it's well known that other soldiers who DID NOT take part in the defence stood in. You could say to complete the picture!

Posts : 2558 Join date : 2009-04-06 Age : 61 Location : UK

Ulundi wrote:: Is a case of rude awakening or headlock. I think not! It just goes to show that some people are willing to accept what they are told to accept, because others say so.

Then there are others who seek alittle more, before they accept it as fact, if that is the case. I don't think JW is doing this to get an apology, he is doing to set the record straight. The poll was a close run thing, that showed what I have said above.

Wouldn't be so sure, perhaps Julian feels he has a score to settle.

"Have you knife and fork ready Impi" Suspect

Guest

"I remember Hook well; but he was not in my battalion. I was in the 1st, and he was a private in the 'B' Company of the second 24th. I recollect now," LOL LOL LOL

Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44

Come on, as Julian says. It was 30 years after the event, he's bound to have forgotten some things about the battle.

Being there might have help?

» Pte David Jenkins. 'Forgotten' Survivor of Rorke's Drift Returned to Official Records
» PTE DAVID JENKINS vs Pte J edmund Jenkins
» David Jenkins topic locked.