Latest topics | » 100,000 posts!Sun Mar 17, 2024 11:14 am by ADMIN» Your favourite line from Zulu or Zulu DawnSat Mar 16, 2024 2:47 pm by jgregory » Zulu Dawn/Zulu - New Immortals Film The Way Forward ?Sat Mar 16, 2024 2:34 pm by jgregory » Badge on 2/60th and 3/60th foreign service helmets Sat Mar 16, 2024 11:05 am by John Young » Corporal James Frowen Williams F Company. Fri Mar 15, 2024 9:08 am by Julian Whybra » British rations and moraleMon Mar 11, 2024 11:05 pm by Julian Whybra » Blue Plaque to James Egan, alias Private HaganMon Mar 11, 2024 9:16 pm by ADMIN» A few questions regarding Rorke's Drift and IsandlwanaWed Mar 06, 2024 9:16 pm by Julian Whybra » William J Hoare 24th Regiment??Sun Mar 03, 2024 7:08 pm by Dash » Swinburn Carbine issue in AZWThu Feb 29, 2024 12:53 pm by Rob D » Australians who went to Zululand and fought in the 1879 war.Thu Feb 29, 2024 8:39 am by John Young » Philip Price Thu Feb 29, 2024 7:55 am by Julian Whybra » Alfred Fairlie Henderson Thu Feb 29, 2024 7:47 am by RoryReynolds » August Hammar Letter Dated 6th Jan 1879Thu Feb 22, 2024 8:34 pm by Stefaan » Bearing The Cross by Ken Blakeson | BBC RADIO DRAMA: Ken Blakeson's play tells the story of the Battle of Rorke's Drift and the effect it had on three of the soldiers who fought in it.Wed Feb 21, 2024 10:57 am by Julian Whybra » Letter of officer during Zulu wars.Wed Feb 21, 2024 10:47 am by Julian Whybra » About the second invasionTue Feb 20, 2024 9:14 pm by 90th » Zulu Festival Brecon July 2024Sat Feb 17, 2024 7:35 pm by John Young » Watford band boys killed at iSandlwanaFri Feb 16, 2024 8:26 am by Julian Whybra » Private J. McCrudden 1/13 Foot Sun Feb 11, 2024 3:10 am by 90th » Death of Michael Jayson (Zulu Dawn)Thu Feb 08, 2024 9:55 pm by ADMIN» The anniversary of 22nd January in 2024Thu Feb 08, 2024 3:51 pm by luke1997 » What was the distance?Thu Feb 08, 2024 8:46 am by Stefaan » Mrs Henry HookTue Feb 06, 2024 3:14 pm by Kenny » "With 6 good riflemen"Mon Feb 05, 2024 2:30 pm by Mr M. Cooper » What was G company supposed to do?Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:31 pm by Julian Whybra » Private 1445 Charles Meates 17th Lancers and his brother William WylieFri Feb 02, 2024 10:07 pm by John Young » South Africa Medal With Clasp To Pvt J. Salter 3/60thFri Feb 02, 2024 3:12 pm by Foody » Weatherleys Border Horse FlagThu Feb 01, 2024 9:40 pm by Herbie » Edward Plantagenet Kemeys-TynteTue Jan 23, 2024 10:06 pm by Edjg » How many started?Tue Jan 23, 2024 10:10 am by Julian Whybra » Firing Line formationMon Jan 22, 2024 2:32 pm by Julian Whybra » Why did Maj. Spalding have to go ?Wed Jan 17, 2024 9:40 pm by Stefaan » Grape-shot at close range.Mon Jan 15, 2024 7:42 am by SRB1965 » Books Hlobane & KambulaTue Jan 09, 2024 10:08 am by John Young |
March 2024 | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun |
---|
| | | | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | Calendar |
|
Top posting users this month | |
New topics | » 100,000 posts!Sun Mar 17, 2024 11:14 am by ADMIN» Badge on 2/60th and 3/60th foreign service helmets Fri Mar 15, 2024 8:27 pm by Rob Herrick » British rations and moraleWed Mar 06, 2024 9:24 pm by Hobbes » Alfred Fairlie Henderson Thu Feb 29, 2024 7:47 am by RoryReynolds » Australians who went to Zululand and fought in the 1879 war.Fri Feb 23, 2024 2:23 am by peterfarrell » About the second invasionSat Feb 17, 2024 9:53 pm by Hobbes » Zulu Festival Brecon July 2024Sat Feb 17, 2024 7:35 pm by John Young » Letter of officer during Zulu wars.Thu Feb 15, 2024 4:46 pm by Will M » Bearing The Cross by Ken Blakeson | BBC RADIO DRAMA: Ken Blakeson's play tells the story of the Battle of Rorke's Drift and the effect it had on three of the soldiers who fought in it.Thu Feb 15, 2024 1:24 am by ADMIN |
Zero tolerance to harassment and bullying. |
Due to recent events on this forum, we have now imposed a zero tolerance to harassment and bullying. All reports will be treated seriously, and will lead to a permanent ban of both membership and IP address.
Any member blatantly corresponding in a deliberate and provoking manner will be removed from the forum as quickly as possible after the event.
If any members are being harassed behind the scenes PM facility by any member/s here at 1879zuluwar.com please do not hesitate to forward the offending text.
We are all here to communicate and enjoy the various discussions and information on the Anglo Zulu War of 1879. Opinions will vary, you will agree and disagree with one another, we will have debates, and so it goes.
There is no excuse for harassment or bullying of anyone by another person on this site.
The above applies to the main frame areas of the forum.
The ring which is the last section on the forum, is available to those members who wish to partake in slagging matches. That section cannot be viewed by guests and only viewed by members that wish to do so. |
Fair Use Notice | Fair use notice.
This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner.
We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes.
We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website.
If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution. |
| | Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query | |
| | Author | Message |
---|
gardner1879
Posts : 3458 Join date : 2021-01-04
| Subject: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sat Jun 05, 2021 4:54 pm | |
| It is often written and many people in our little world believe that M+C were the first to receive the posthumous Victoria Cross. However whilst researching an Indian officer, Charles Edward Salkeld, I stumbled across some information relating to his brother Philip who was awarded the VC posthumously for blowing up the Cashmere gate at the Delhi Fortress in 1857 I checked my go to VC bible (Philip Wilkins 1904) and this confirms the report I found. Lt. Philip Salkeld below [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]So are M+C the first or not? Kate
Last edited by gardner1879 on Sun Jun 06, 2021 8:26 pm; edited 3 times in total |
| | | John Young
Posts : 3229 Join date : 2013-09-08 Age : 68 Location : Слава Україні! Героям слава!
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sat Jun 05, 2021 5:38 pm | |
| Kate, I always thought the spelling was Salkeld, but I am happy to be corrected. When King Edward VII approved the amendment to the Royal Warrant in 1902, permitting the posthumous award of the Victoria Cross previous acts were than considered, those obviously included Home & Salkeld, and Melvill & Coghill. However, it would 1907 before a number of Victoria Crosses were awarded in retrospect see [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]JY |
| | | gardner1879
Posts : 3458 Join date : 2021-01-04
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sat Jun 05, 2021 6:49 pm | |
| The Western Gazette 11th May 1923:- "The Salkeld family first came to Dorsetshire in the early 18th Century and has been prominently identified with the county ever since. The deceased Colonel's elder brother Lt. Philip Salkeld lost his life during the Indian Mutiny were his heroic conduct gained for him the posthumous award of the Victoria Cross (the first time in the history of the honour it had been awarded after death)" Interesting, thanks John. In my 1st edition 'The History of the Victoria Cross by Philip A Wilkins printed 1904 it lists Salkeld with the award being announced in the London Gazette of 1858 [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]The crucial words in this report I suppose being 'had they survived' Odd that they are shown along with M+C and others in a book dated 1904 before the decoration was given. So if we go by date of the action then M+C are not the first to be awarded the posthumous VC. Just idle thoughts Kate
Last edited by gardner1879 on Sun Jun 06, 2021 8:28 pm; edited 1 time in total |
| | | John Young
Posts : 3229 Join date : 2013-09-08 Age : 68 Location : Слава Україні! Героям слава!
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sat Jun 05, 2021 8:23 pm | |
| Kate, Melvill & Coghill’s recommendations also appeared as a Memorandum in The London Gazette see [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]I have always considered Frederick Hugh Sherston Roberts’ award for his actions at Colenso in 1899 to have been the exception to the Royal Warrant. See [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]JY |
| | | Kenny
Posts : 584 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sun Jun 06, 2021 7:46 pm | |
| John
The key words in the case of Roberts citation is ‘since deceased’. And in the case of Mevill and Coghill ‘had he survived he would have been recommended for the Victoria Cross’
The two aspects which makes me grit my teeth (1) most people refer to the VC as a medal - it is not. The Royal Warrant specially states that it is a decoration. And the senior of all British decorations, including the Order of the Garter (i.e Robert’s senior - Field Marshal VC KG KP GCB OM GSSI GCIE VD) . (2) Most people again say ‘he won a VC’. The word ‘won’ is incorrect - in warfare it is not a competition there is no second place as old senior military friend of mine would keep reminding me. You are AWARDED a VC. |
| | | gardner1879
Posts : 3458 Join date : 2021-01-04
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sun Jun 06, 2021 9:04 pm | |
| As a caring sort of a person, I hope the following helps prevent wear and tear to your gnashers Kenny English dictionary definition:- Medal- Small flat piece of medal bearing an inscription or image given as an award or commemoration of some outstanding action or event etc. Win- to succeed in or gain (something) with an effort....... to achieve recognition in some field of endeavour.........to gain victory or triumph or victory in a battle... So what do we think chaps are M+C the first to receive the award or is it Mr Salkeld? Kate |
| | | Kenny
Posts : 584 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Sun Jun 06, 2021 11:57 pm | |
| Kate,
The answer to your specific question about M+C is no. A number of authors writing about AZW tend to embellish the facts for the sake of good story. In fact there were 5 other posthumous VC awards in addition to Lt Roberts made in ABW and confirmed in the LG 8 Aug 1902 (p5085). M+C not confirmed until LG 15 Jan 1907 (p325) even though memorandum entries were published in LG 1 May 1879. The earliest posthumous award in 15 Jan 1907 gazette is Pte Edward Spence 42F whose action was 15 Apr 1858. He died two days later of wounds received on 15 Apr.
Turning Lt Salkeld, he along with Lt Duncan Charles Home were recognised for their gallantry for the action in the Mutiny which took place at the Cashmere Gate Delhi on 14 Sep 1857. Their recommendation is written up as a memorandum entry and published LG 18 Jun 1858 (p2961) by which date each officer had been killed in a subsequent action - Home on 1 Oct 1857 and Salkeld on 10 Oct 1857. I cannot find a later London Gazette entry confirming these awards. So I assume the authorities treated them as non-posthumous as Home and Salkeld did not die in the actual action of the award. If you consider that these are posthumous awards then is it Home or Salkeld should be first. Home because he died first?
|
| | | gardner1879
Posts : 3458 Join date : 2021-01-04
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Mon Jun 07, 2021 9:04 pm | |
| Thanks Kenny I do find it slightly odd though that it is stated that Salkeld died at another action a month later. The report from a witness, Sergeant Smith, who was at the gate with him stated that Salkeld was shot in the thigh, blown up, fell off a bridge and broke both his arms. Also a Naick stretcher bearer claimed Salkeld died before getting to the surgeon. He must be a fast healer to be back in action a month later Kate |
| | | Kenny
Posts : 584 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Wed Jun 09, 2021 8:56 am | |
| Dear Kate,
I have fallen victim of the worldwide web whilst not being able to actually be able to consult the archives and original documents to able to double check the facts.
Someone needs to correct the Wkipedia entry for Philip Salkeld VC. It seems he did die on 1 Oct 1857 or 10 Oct 1857 - having had a limb amputated without anaesthetic following the action on 14 Sep 1857 at the Cashmere Gate. It does also appear he was visited in bed by General Wilson who confirmed an immediate VC award, subject to later HM approval, in line with clause 7 of VC Royal Warrant. Although the citation published in the LG is written up as a 'memorandum' entry, the invention of General Wilson suggest that the awards to Lts Home and Salkeld were treated as immediate awards, and not posthumous.
As you know these gallantry awards, are assessed by the recipient's peers at the time. In combat times, weapon systems and conditions do change. Also the Great War saw additional gallantry awards introduced to recognise the many lesser heroic deeds. It is very difficult to compare circumstances - each VC recipient has met the criteria to receive Britain's highest gallantry award.
However, what we cannot do is 'rank' the awards, such as 'the first'. Yes, it is incorrect to refer M+C as the 'first' posthumous awards. Probably, as suggested the Lt Roberts award is not the first posthumous award but it did open discussion to change the rules - to allow subsequent posthumous awards and for earlier memorandum awards to be recognised.
On a number of occasions, I have sat on the veranda of the replacement hospital building at Rorke's Drift and imagined what it was like at 4pm 22 Jan 1879 when the many Zulus attacked the small mission station following the earlier defeat of Imperial forces at Isandlwana. I would been very scared and frightened. The subsequent VC awards to 11 of the defenders were all deserved that day.
|
| | | gardner1879
Posts : 3458 Join date : 2021-01-04
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Wed Jun 09, 2021 9:18 am | |
| Morning Kenny Thanks for posting details about Salkeld's death. Very interesting. Agree with you 100% about the Rorke's Drift V.C.s. Each one was well deserved. Whenever I'm there I like to sit on the bank were Scheiss gained his V.C. and try and put myself in their shoes. It must have been horrific. I also think Alan should have won the V.C. for his actions on the 22nd/23rd but thats for a different thread altogether Kate |
| | | John Young
Posts : 3229 Join date : 2013-09-08 Age : 68 Location : Слава Україні! Героям слава!
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Wed Jun 09, 2021 12:38 pm | |
| Kate,
You might want amend ‘Scheiss’ to Schiess, scheiss is what the defenders must have thought they were in.
As to being in Schiess’ shoes don’t forget they blister.
JY |
| | | gardner1879
Posts : 3458 Join date : 2021-01-04
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Wed Jun 09, 2021 1:17 pm | |
| Thanks for your imput Jhon Kate |
| | | Kenny
Posts : 584 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Wed Jun 09, 2021 5:52 pm | |
| Kate,
It would appear that the VC awards to Lts Home and Salkeld were treated as straight forward immediate awards. The Queen approval was published in the London Gazette Tuesday 27 April 1858 (page 2051) and on the following day 28 April 1858 in the Times newspaper. So neither were treated as posthumous awards as they did not die in the action of the award. |
| | | SRB1965
Posts : 1198 Join date : 2017-05-13 Age : 59 Location : Uttoxeter - the last place God made and he couldn't be bothered to finish it.....
| Subject: Re: Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query Mon Jul 12, 2021 6:33 pm | |
| The report from a witness, Sergeant Smith, who was at the gate with him stated that Salkeld was shot in the thigh, blown up, fell off a bridge and broke both his arms.
Ahhh that would be Phil 'lucky' Salkeld? |
| | | | Melvill and Coghill Victoria Cross query | |
|
Similar topics | |
|
| Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |